• Ingen resultater fundet

1&45*$*%"'13˜7/*/(

N/A
N/A
Info
Hent
Protected

Academic year: 2022

Del "1&45*$*%"'13˜7/*/("

Copied!
170
0
0

Indlæser.... (se fuldtekst nu)

Hele teksten

(1)

1&45*$*%"'13˜7/*/(

%+'3"11035."3,#36(Ţ."354

-*4&/*45361+˜3(&/4&/#&/5+/*&-4&/,"3&/&#&3)"3%5)&/3*,4&/

40-7&+(."5)*"44&/,-"641""4,&

(2)

*/45*565'031-"/5&#&4,:55&-4&0(

4,"%&%:3

%&5+03%#36(47*%&/

4,"#&-*(&'",6-5&5

1&45*$*%"'13˜7/*/(

-JTF/JTUSVQ+¸SHFOTFO#FOU+/JFMTFO,BSFO&CFSIBSEU)FOSJLTFO4PMWFKH.BUIJBTTFO ,MBVT1BBTLF

*OTUJUVUGPS1MBOUFCFTLZUUFMTFPH4LBEFEZS

%FU+PSECSVHTWJEFOTLBCFMJHF'BLVMUFU

"BSIVT6OJWFSTJUFU 'PSTªHTWFK 4MBHFMTF

3BQQPSUFSOFJOEFIPMEFSIPWFETBHFMJHGPSTLOJOHT SFTVMUBUFSPHGPSTªHTPQHªSFMTFSSFUUFUNPEEBOTLF GPSIPME&OEWJEFSFLBOEFCFTLSJWFTUªSSFTBN MFEFGPSTLOJOHTQSPKFLUFSFMMFSGVOHFSFTPNCJMBH UJMUFNBNªEFS

3BQQPSUFSOFVELPNNFSJTFSJFSOF .BSLCSVH)VTEZSCSVH)BWFCSVH

"CPOOFOUFSPQO˜SSBCBUPHBCPOOFNFOULBO UFHOFTWFEIFOWFOEFMTFUJM

%FU+PSECSVHTWJEFOTLBCFMJHF'BLVMUFU

"BSIVT6OJWFSTJUFU 1PTUCPLT5KFMF 5MG

"MMFQVCMJLBUJPOFSLBOCFTUJMMFTQ˜OFUUFU XXXBHSTDJBVEL

5SZLXXXEJHJTPVSDFEL

*4#/

(3)
(4)

,QGKROGVIRUWHJQHOVH

)RURUG , %HVNULYHOVHDIY NVWV VRQHQ

.OLPDIRUKROGLY NVWV VRQHQ

6\JGRPVDQJUHE

,, %HN PSHOVHDIVYDPSHV\JGRPPHLNRUQ

6'+,¶HUHOOHUFDUER[DPLGHUHQQ\JUXSSHIXQJLFLGHU

$ISU¡YQLQJDIQ\HIXQJLFLGHU

%HN PSHOVHDIVHSWRULDPHGWULD]ROHURJWULD]ROEODQGLQJHU

5HVLVWHQVXGYLNOLQJRYHUIRUWULD]ROHU

%HN PSHOVHDI)XVDULXPPHGIXQJLFLGHU

%HN PSHOVHDIPHOGXJLKYHGH

%HN PSHOVHDI'75LKYHGH

6RUWHUVPRGWDJHOLJKHGRYHUIRU)XVDULXP

6WUDWHJLIRUV¡JLYnUE\J

6WUDWHJLIRUV¡JLYLQWHUE\J

6\JGRPVEHN PSHOVHLIU¡JU V

,,, %HN PSHOVHVVWUDWHJLHULIRUVNHOOLJHNRUQVRUWHU

,9 %HN PSHOVHDIVYDPSHV\JGRPPHLPDMV

9 %HN PSHOVHDIVYDPSHV\JGRPPHLVXNNHUURHU

9, )XQJLFLGEHKDQGOLQJHUVLQGÀ\GHOVHSnNHUQHNYDOLWHWHQ 9,, %HN PSHOVHDIVYDPSHV\JGRPPHLNDUWRÀHU

9,,, 6NDGHG\ULODQGEUXJVDIJU¡GHU

%HN PSHOVHDIJOLPPHUE¡VVHULUDSVPHG6WHZDUG

%HN PSHOVHDINRUQEODGELOOHUPHG$YDXQW

%HN PSHOVHDIIULWÀXHUPHG&\SHUE

,; %HN PSHOVHDIDJHUU YHKDOH

; 5HVXOWDWHUIUDDISU¡YQLQJHQPHGKHUELFLGHURJY NVWUHJXOHULQJVPLGOHU

;, .HPLNDOLHRYHUVLJW

(5)

(6)

)RURUG

3XEOLNDWLRQHQLQGHKROGHUUHVXOWDWHUIUDnUHWVIRUV¡JPHGSHVWLFLGHULODQGEUXJVDIJU¡GHURJIRNX VHUHUSULP UWSnUHVXOWDWHUPHGQ\HSHVWLFLGHUKHUXQGHUWLOEDJHEOLNSnGHnUKYRUPLGOHUQHKDU Y UHDISU¡YHW5HVXOWDWHUQHHULYLGXGVWU NQLQJSU VHQWHUHWYHGKM OSDIJUD¿NRJRYHUVLJWHU

3XEOLNDWLRQHQ RPKDQGOHU GHVXGHQ nUHWV JDQJ L DIJU¡GHUQH PHG KHQV\Q WLO V\JGRPV RJ VNDGHG\UVXGYLNOLQJHQ%RJHQHUHWVXSSOHPHQWWLOGHUHVXOWDWE¡JHUGHUKYHUWnUSURGXFHUHVIUD ,QVWLWXWIRU3ODQWHEHVN\WWHOVHRJ6NDGHG\U

5HVXOWDWHUYHGU¡UHQGHQ\HSURGXNWHURJPDUNHGVI¡UWHPLGOHUYLOL¡YULJWLQGJnLGHQnUOLJH RSGDWHULQJDIUnGJLYQLQJVSURJUDPPHW3ODQWHY UQ2QOLQH0DQJHDIUHVXOWDWHUQHLnUHWVERJHU UHVXOWDWHUIUDHQNHOWIRUV¡JHOOHUIRUV¡JVVHULHU,ÀHUHWLOI OGHHUIRUV¡JIUDÀHUHnURJVnVDPOHW

%RJHQHUVDPOHWRJUHGLJHUHWDI/LVH1LVWUXS-¡UJHQVHQRJ.DUHQ(EHUKDUGW+HQULNVHQ,QVWL WXWIRU3ODQWHEHVN\WWHOVHRJ6NDGHG\U)RUVNQLQJVFHQWHU)ODNNHEMHUJ

'HUUHWWHVHQWDNWLODOOHGHUKDUELGUDJHWPHGWLOYHMHEULQJHOVHDIGHYLVWHUHVXOWDWHU'HWY UH VLJNHPLNDOLH¿UPDHUVRPV OJHUSHVLFLGHUSULYDWHIRUV¡JVY UWHUODQGERIRUHQLQJHURJSHUVR QDOHYHG'HW-RUGEUXJVYLGHQVNDEHOLJH)DNXOWHW

)RUVNHUJUXSSHQIRU3HVWLFLGIRUVNQLQJRJ0LOM¡NHPL ,QVWLWXWIRU3ODQWHEHVN\WWHOVHRJ6NDGHG\U

$DUKXV8QLYHUVLWHW

(7)

(8)

3HVWLFLGDISU¡YQLQJ

, %HVNULYHOVHDIY NVWnUHW

8GSOXNDI*U¡Q9LGHQ%LUJLW6¡UHQVHQ /LVH1LVWUXS-¡UJHQVHQ

.OLPDIRUKROGLY NVWV VRQHQ

9 NVWnUHWVRPKHOKHGYDUOLGWYnGHUHHQGQRU PDOW'HUIDOGWPPPHUHQHGE¡UHQGQRU PDOW RJ IRUGDPSQLQJHQ YDU K¡MHUH HQG QRUPDOW6WUnOLQJHQYDUK¡MHUHHQGQRUPDOW RJPLGGHOWHPSHUDWXUHQYDUOLJPHGQRUPDOHQ IRUY NVWnUHWcUHWYDUSU JHWDIVWRUHQHGE¡UV K QGHOVHULHIWHUnUHWRJVLGVWSnY NVWV VR QHQKYRULPRGGHWWLGOLJHIRUnUYDUPHJHWW¡UW 0LGGHOWHPSHUDWXUHQLHIWHUnUHWYDUK¡MRJLJHQ LMXOLYDUPLGGHOWHPSHUDWXUHQPHJHWK¡M )RUHO¡ELJH PnQHGVY UGLHU IRU WHPSHUDWXU QHGE¡USRWHQWLHOIRUGDPSQLQJRJJOREDOVWUn OLQJHUYLVWLWDEHO0nQHGVY UGLHUQHHULWD EHOOHQVDPPHQOLJQHWPHGGHQRUPDOHY UGLHU IRUSHULRGHQ

)LJXU YLVHU NOLPDGDWD IUD )ODNNHEMHUJ L Y NVWV VRQHQ )LJXUHQ LQGHKROGHU GDWD IRU WHPSHUDWXU QHGE¡U JOREDO LQGVWUnOLQJ RJ

YDQGEDODQFH,¿JXUYLVHVYDQGEDODQFHQIRU PnQHGHUQHDSULOWLODXJXVWGDJOLJWVXPPHUHW QHGE¡U PLQXV SRWHQWLHO IRUGDPSQLQJ KYRU YDQGEDODQFHQ IRU PnQHGHQ V WWHV WLO KYLV GHQ EOLYHU QHJDWLY OLJHVRP GHU HU HQ ¿JXU VRPVXPPHUHUYDQGEDODQFHIRUSHULRGHQDSULO WLORJPHGDXJXVW

(IWHUnU

(IWHUnUHW VRP KHOKHG YDU OXQ VROULJ RJ YnG 0LGGHOWHPSHUDWXUHQYDUƒ&RYHUQRUPDOHQ RJGHUIDOGWPPPHUHQHGE¡UHQGQRUPDOW 6WUnOLQJHQYDURYHUQRUPDOHQ

6HSWHPEHUYDUW¡URJVROULJ'HUIDOGWPP PLQGUHQHGE¡UHQGQRUPDOWRJVWUnOLQJHQYDU ODYHUHHQGQRUPDOW0LGGHOWHPSHUDWXUHQ YDUƒ&K¡MHUHHQGQRUPDOWRJIRUGDPSQLQ JHQYDUPPK¡MHUHHQGQRUPDOW

7HPSHUDWXU

ƒ& 1HGE¡U

PP 3RWHQWLHOIRUGDPSQLQJ

PP *OREDOVWUnOLQJ 0-Pñ 0LGGHO 1RUPDO $EVROXW $NWXHO 1RUPDO $NWXHO 1RUPDO $NWXHO 1RUPDO

0LQ 0DNV

6HSWHPEHU

2NWREHU

1RYHPEHU

'HFHPEHU

-DQXDU

)HEUXDU

0DUWV

$SULO

0DM

-XQL

-XOL

$XJXVW

cUHW

7DEHO)RUHO¡ELJHPnQHGVY UGLHUIRUWHPSHUDWXUQHGE¡USRWHQWLHOIRUGDPSQLQJRJJOREDO VWUnOLQJIRU'DQPDUN.LOGH'DQPDUNV0HWHRURORJLVNH,QVWLWXW

(9)

2NWREHUEOHYNROGRJPHGRYHUVNXGDIVRO 0LGGHOWHPSHUDWXUHQYDUƒ&ODYHUHHQGQRU PDOW I¡UVWH IURVWGDJ IDOGW PLGW L PnQHGHQ L 0LGWM\OODQGRJVWUnOLQJHQYDUK¡MHUHHQG QRUPDOW'HUIDOGWQHGE¡UQ VWHQVRPQRUPDOW QHPOLJNXQPPPHUH

1RYHPEHUV NOLPD YDU PHJHW YDUPW PHJHW YnGWRJPHJHWVROIDWWLJW0LGGHOWHPSHUDWXUHQ YDUƒ&K¡MHUHHQGQRUPDOWRJGHUIDOGW PHUH QHGE¡U HQG QRUPDOW RJ VWUnOLQJHQ YDU ODYHUHHQGQRUPDOW$QWDOOHWDIQHGE¡UV G¡JQLQRYHPEHUEOHYKYLONHWHUUHNRUGIRU SHULRGHQKYRU'0,KDUUHJLVWUHUHW

6nDUEHMGHWEOHYLVWLOOHWRYHUIRUIRU VNHOOLJHXGIRUGULQJHUDOWHIWHUORNDOLWHW,-\O ODQG RJ Sn )\Q IDOGW VWRUH P QJGHU QHGE¡U I¡UVW L VHSWHPEHU PHQV GHU Sn 6M OODQG YDU VnW¡UWDWMRUGHQYDUVY UDWNRPPHL6LGVWL VHSWHPEHUYDUVW¡UVWHGHOHQDIYLQWHUV GHQGRJ VnHW0DMVK¡VWHQVWDUWHGHLVOXWQLQJHQDIVHSWHP EHURJPLGWLRNWREHUNRPGHUXGEUHGWQDWWH

IURVWVRPJMRUGHDWPDMVHQVWRUWVHWYDUK¡VWHW LVOXWQLQJHQDIRNWREHU

3nWURGVDIVLGVWHVRPPHUVPDVVLYHDQJUHE DIEODGOXVEOHYGHUNXQUHJLVWUHUHWJDQVNHIn DQJUHEDIEODGOXVLKYHGHLO¡EHWDIHIWHUnUHW 9LQWHU

9LQWHUHQYDUNROGRJPHGXQGHUVNXGDIQHG E¡U0LGGHOWHPSHUDWXUHQYDUƒ&XQGHUQRU PDOHQRJGHUIDOGWPPPLQGUHQHGE¡UHQG QRUPDOW0HJHWDIGHQQHGE¡UGHUIDOGWNRPL IRUPDIVQH

'HFHPEHUYDUNROG0LGGHOWHPSHUDWXUHQYDU

ƒ&XQGHUQRUPDOHQGHUEOHYUHJLVWUHUHWKHOW QHGWLOƒ&YHG+RUVHQV1HGE¡UHQRJVWUn OLQJHQYDUOLGWK¡MHUHHQGQRUPDOW

-DQXDUEOHYPHJHWNROGRJPHGRYHUVNXGDI VRORJXQGHUVNXGDIQHGE¡U0LGGHOWHPSHUDWX UHQYDUƒ&XQGHUQRUPDOHQ'HUIDOGW PLQGUHQHGE¡UHQGQRUPDOWRJVWUnOLQJHQYDU K¡MHUHHQGQRUPDOW

)HEUXDUEOHYHQGQXHQNROGPnQHG0LGGHO )LJXUH.OLPDHWSn)RUVNQLQJVFHQWHU)ODNNHEMHUJLY NVWV VRQHQVHSWHPEHUDXJXVW 7HPSHUDWXUHQHUPnOWLƒ&GHQJOREDOHLQGVWUnOLQJHUPnOWL0-PQHGE¡UHQLPPRJ YDQGEDODQFHQHUIRUVNHOOHQPHOOHPQHGE¡URJSRWHQWLHOIRUGDPSQLQJ

(10)

WHPSHUDWXUHQYDUƒ&XQGHUQRUPDOHQ1HG

E¡URJVWUnOLQJYDUW WYHGQRUPDOHQ

'HQPHJHQVQHRJGHODYHWHPSHUDWXUHUYDU VN\OGLDWVSHFLHOWYLQWHUKYHGHQLNNHNODUHGH VLJJRGW0DQJHYLQWHUV GVPDUNHU¿NDQJUHE DIVQHVNLPPHOLV UKYRUGHUYDUVWRUWVQHG N NH 6SHFLHOW L GHW QRUG¡VWOLJH -\OODQG PnWWH KHOHPDUNHUHOOHUSOHWWHULPDUNHUQHVnVRPWLO YnUV G1RJOHJU VPDUNHUEOHYRJVnUDPWDI VQHVNLPPHOVRPJMRUGHDWGHVNXOOHQ\HWDE OHUHV

6QHHQRJGHQIURVQHMRUGYDURJVnJUXQGHQ WLODWJ\OOHXGN¡UVOHQPnWWHXGV WWHVSnJUXQG DIULVLNRIRUDWJ\OOHQO¡EY NLIRUELQGHOVH PHGW¡EUXG.Y OVWRISURJQRVHQHQGWHPHGDW

Y UHQ VWHQQHXWUDORJVnSULP UWVRPI¡OJH DIYLQWHUYHMUHW

)RUnU

)RUnUHWVRPKHOKHGYDUW¡UW'HUIDOGWPP PLQGUH QHGE¡U HQG QRUPDOW )RUGDPSQLQJHQ YDUPPK¡MHUHHQGQRUPDOWPLGGHOWHPSH UDWXUHQRJVWUnOLQJHQYDUOLGWRYHUQRUPDOHQ 0DUWVEOHYW¡URJVROULJ'HUIDOGWPPPLQ GUHQHGE¡UHQGQRUPDOWRJVWUnOLQJHQYDU K¡MHUH HQG QRUPDOW 6HOY RP PLGGHOWHPSH UDWXUHQYDUOLGWK¡MHUHHQGQRUPDOWVnKDYGH GHQVWRUHXGVYLQJIUDVWDUWHQDIPnQHGHQKYRU YLQWHUHQVWDGLJKXVHUHGHRJWHPSHUDWXUHQYDU QHGHSnƒ&L‘VWM\OODQGWLOVOXWQLQJHQDI )LJXU9DQGEDODQFHLY NVWV VRQHQ

(11)

PnQHGHQKYRUK¡MHVWHWHPSHUDWXUYDUƒ&

VRPEOHYUHJLVWUHUHWL1RUGVM OODQG

$SULOYDUYDUPVROULJRJIRUKROGVYLVW¡U0LG GHOWHPSHUDWXUHQYDUƒ&RYHUQRUPDOHQRJ VWUnOLQJHQ YDU K¡MHUH HQG QRUPDOW 'HU IDOGWPLQGUHQHGE¡UPHQGHUYDUIRUVNHO OHRYHUODQGHW)RUGDPSQLQJHQYDUK¡MHUH HQGQRUPDOW

0DMEOHYNROGPHGRYHUVNXGDIQHGE¡URJXQ GHUVNXGDIVRO0LGGHOWHPSHUDWXUHQYDUƒ&

XQGHUQRUPDOHQRJY NVWnUHWVVLGVWHIURVWGDJ EOHYUHJLVWUHUHWVnVHQWVRPGHQPHQRJVn VHQHUHYDUGHUIURVWPRUJHQHUSnXGVDWWHVWHGHU 'HUIDOGWPHUHQHGE¡UHQGQRUPDOW6WUn OLQJHQYDUXQGHUQRUPDOHQRJIRUGDPS QLQJHQW WYHGQRUPDOHQ

3nJUXQGDIGHWNROGHYLQWHUYHMUYDUMRUGHQ LNNHNODUWLOVnQLQJI¡ULVWDUWHQDIDSULORJOLJH OHGHVIRUWVDWWHE\JHYHMULDSULOPHGDWGLVWUDKH UHVnQLQJHQ,1RUGM\OODQGKYRUPHJHWVNXOOH VnVRPSnJUXQGDIXGYLQWULQJYDUPDQLV U O QJHRPDWInDOOHPDUNHUQHVnHWWLO3nJUXQG DIW¡UNHKDYGHGHWVHQWVnHGHNRUQL1RUGM\O ODQGVY UWYHGDWVSLUHIUHP7¡UNHQJMRUGH DWGHUWLGOLJWNRPJDQJLYDQGLQJVPDVNLQHUQH PHQ VWRUH QHGE¡UVP QJGHU L PDM VDWWH LJHQ JDQJLY NVWHQ

'HQNROGHMRUGJMRUGHDWO JQLQJHQDINDU WRÀHUI¡UVWJLNLJDQJPHGLRDSULORJDIJU¡GHQ

¿NHQGnUOLJVWDUWSnJUXQGDIGHWNROGHYHMUL PDM2JVnPDMVHQEOHYVnHWVHQHUHHQGQRUPDOW RJKDYGHHQVY UVWDUWLGHWNROGHYHMU

'HWNROGHYHMULPDMJMRUGHDWGHULIRUnUHW YDUI UUHVNDGHG\U'HQPHJHQQHGE¡ULPDM VDWWHJDQJLDQJUHEHQHDIIXJWHOVNHQGHVYDPSH VRPVHSWRULDLKYHGHQRJVNROGSOHWLE\JPHQ GHWHIWHUI¡OJHQGHW¡UUHVRPPHUYHMUPLQGVNHGH GRJDQJUHEHQHVnOHGHVDWGHIRUEOHYUHODWLYW PRGHUDWH'HQVWUHQJHYLQWHUPHGYLUNHGHWLO DWEHJU QVHRYHUYLQWULQJHQDIUXVWV\JGRPPH .XQLWULWLFDOHNXQQHPDQLPRGWDJHOLJHVRUWHU VHEHW\GHOLJHDQJUHE

6RPPHU

6RPPHUHQYDUYnGRJOXQ'HUIDOGWPHUH QHGE¡UHQGQRUPDOWVRPGRJSULP UWIDOGWL DXJXVWRJPLGGHOWHPSHUDWXUHQYDUƒ&RYHU

QRUPDOHQ)RUGDPSQLQJHQYDUK¡MHUHHQG QRUPDOWRJVWUnOLQJHQYDUK¡MHUHHQGQRU PDOW-XQLYDUNROGRJPHGRYHUVNXGDIVRO0LG GHOWHPSHUDWXUHQ YDU ƒ& XQGHU QRUPDOHQ RJVWUnOLQJHQYDURYHUQRUPDOHQ1HGE¡

UHQYDUXQGHUQRUPDOHQRJIRUGDPSQLQJHQ RYHUQRUPDOHQ

-XOLYDUYDUPVROULJRJPHGK¡MIRUGDPSQLQJ 0LGGHOWHPSHUDWXUHQYDUƒ&K¡MHUHHQGQRU PDOWRJVWUnOLQJHQYDUK¡MHUHHQGQRUPDOW 'HUIDOGWPHUHQHGE¡UHQGQRUPDOWRJIRU GDPSQLQJHQYDUK¡MHUHHQGQRUPDOW

$XJXVWEOHYPHJHWYnGRJVROIDWWLJ'HUIDOGW PHUHQHGE¡U HQG QRUPDOWRJ PnQHGHQ YDUSU JHWDIÀHUHNUDIWLJHQHGE¡UVK QGHOVHU VSHFLHOWLGHW¡VWOLJH'DQPDUN)RUGDPSQLQ JHQYDUXQGHUQRUPDOHQRJVWUnOLQJHQYDU XQGHUQRUPDOHQ0LGGHOWHPSHUDWXUHQYDU

ƒ&RYHUQRUPDOHQ

5RHURJPDMVKDYGHEHJJHHQGnUOLJVWDUW (IWHU IUHPVSLULQJ VWRG GHUHV Y NVW VWRUW VHW VWLOOHSnJUXQGDIGHQN¡OLJHIRUVRPPHU6H QHUHNRPGHUGRJJRGY NVWLDIJU¡GHUQH,QG WLOVOXWQLQJHQDIMXOLYDUPDMVYDUPHHQKHGHUQH XQGHUQRUPDOHQ

0LGWLMXQLEOHYGHQI¡UVWHNDUWRIIHOVNLP PHONRQVWDWHUHWSn6DPV¡RJL1RUGM\OODQGRJ GHWIXJWLJHYHMULO¡EHWDIVRPPHUHQJMRUGHDW VSU¡MWHEHKRYHWYDUVWRUW

'HQODQJHYLQWHURJGHUHIWHUGHWYDUPHRJ W¡UUHIRUnUVSHFLHOWL1RUGRJ9HVWM\OODQGEH W¡GDWGHUYDUVWRUHIRUVNHOOHSnK¡VWXGE\WWHW UXQGWRPLODQGHW+¡VWHQDIIU¡JU VRJYLQWHU E\JJLNLJDQJPHGLRMXOLGHUHIWHUIXOJWHK¡

VWHQDIUDSVRJYnUE\J,VWDUWHQDIDXJXVWJLN K¡VWHQDIYLQWHUKYHGHLJDQJPHQGHWYDUGRJ QRJOHVWHGHUOLGWEHVY UOLJWDWK¡VWHSnJUXQG DIKXOOHUWLOVnHWPHGDQGUHNRUQVRUWHU

'HWPHJHWXVWDGLJHYHMULI¡UVWHKDOYGHODI DXJXVWVDWWHHQPLGOHUWLGLJVWRSSHUIRUK¡VWHQ KYRUGHUÀHUHVWHGHUNRPVnPHJHWYDQGDWGHW YDUSUREOHPDWLVNDWN¡UHPHGGHWXQJHPDVNL QHUOLJHVRPGHULPDQJHPDUNHUYDUSUREOH PHUPHGVSLUHQGHNHUQHULDNVHW6LGVWLDXJXVW NRPGHUGRJHQSHULRGHPHGEO VWRJW¡UNH VRPJMRUGHDWPDUNHUQHW¡UUHGHRJGHULJHQ

(12)

NXQQHNRPPHJDQJLPHMHW UVNHUQH(QGHO NRUQEOHYK¡VWHWPHGHQK¡MYDQGSURFHQWRJ QHGVDWVSLUHHYQHOLJHVRPEO VWHQLVLGVWHIDVH DIK¡VWHQJDYDQOHGQLQJWLOVSLOGDINHUQHUHOOHU DNVIUDGHRYHUPRGQHDIJU¡GHU0HGXGJDQJHQ DIDXJXVWYDUFDDINRUQHWK¡VWHWRJPHG ULPHOLJH XGE\WWHU RPNULQJ HOOHU OLGW XQGHU JHQQHPVQLWWHW

.RQNOXVLRQHU

9 NVWnUHWVRPKHOKHGYDUYnGHUHHQGQRUPDOW 'HU IDOGW PP PHUH QHGE¡U HQG QRUPDOW RJIRUGDPSQLQJHQYDUK¡MHUHHQGQRPDOW 6WUnOLQJHQYDUK¡MHUHHQGQRUPDOWRJPLG GHOWHPSHUDWXUHQ YDU OLJ PHG QRUPDOHQ 'RJ YDUPLGGHOWHPSHUDWXUHQLMXOLPHJHWK¡McUHW YDUSU JHWDINUDIWLJHQHGE¡UVK QGHOVHULHI WHUnUHWRJVLGVWSnY NVWV VRQHQ

‡ 'HQPHJHQVQHRJGHODYHWHPSHUDWXUHUYDU VN\OGLDWVSHFLHOWYLQWHUKYHGHQLNNHNOD UHGHVLJJRGWSnPDQJHORNDOLWHWHU0DQJH YLQWHUV GVPDUNHU ¿N DQJUHE DI VQHVNLP PHOLV UKYRUGHUYDUW\NWVQHG NNH

‡ 'HQNROGHMRUGRJVHQHUHW¡UNHJMRUGHPDQ JHVWHGHUDWIRUnUVDIJU¡GHUQHKDYGHVY UW YHGDWHWDEOHUHVLJ

‡ 8VWDGLJWYHMULDXJXVWJDYSUREOHPHUPHG K¡VWHQ

3nJUXQGDIPHJHWUHJQXQGHUNRUQHWVPRG QLQJYDUGHUVWRUHSUREOHPHUPHGVSLULQJDI NHUQHULDNVHW

9LQWHUHQE¡GSnODQJYDULJVQHG NNHRJEH W\GHOLJHDQJUHEDIVQHVNLPPHONXQQHVHVLGHW WLGOLJHIRUnU0HJHWYLQWHUV GPnWWHVnVRPL GHOHDIODQGHW

,PDUWVPnQHGYDUGHULNNHPHJHWJDQJLDIJU¡

GHUQHHIWHUGHQODQJHYLQWHU0HQDIJU¡GHUQH NRPLJDQJRJJDYS QHXGE\WWHUVHOYRPGHW LNNHEOHYWLOWRSXGE\WWHU

(13)

6\JGRPVDQJUHE

/LVH1LVWUXS-¡UJHQVHQ%HQW-1LHOVHQ +HOHQH6DOWRIW.ULVWMDQVHQ

,GHWWHDIVQLWQ YQHVIRUWULQVYLVKYLONHIRUH NRPVWHUGHUKDUY UHWDIVYDPSHV\JGRPPHL IRUV¡JHQHL'HWWHJ¡UGHWPXOLJWDWYXU GHUHLKYLONHWRPIDQJVNDGHJ¡UHUHQKDUY UHW WLOVWHGHRJGHUPHGSnKYLONHWQLYHDXnUHWVUH VXOWDWHUKDUY UHWUHSU VHQWDWLYH

+YHGH

+YHGHPHOGXJ %OXPHULD JUDPLQLV $Q JUHEVJUDGHUQHLYDUJHQHUHOWODYHWLOPR GHUDWHSnGHÀHVWHORNDOLWHWHU$QJUHEHQHYDU GRJEHW\GHOLJHSnEnGH)ODNNHEMHUJRJSn-\Q GHYDGIRUV¡JVVWDWLRQ6LGVWQ YQWHHUNHQGWIRU VLQHNUDIWLJHDQJUHEKYLONHWRJVnKROGWVWLNIRU

%HG¡PPHOVHUIUDUHJLVWUHULQJVQHWWHWYL VWHDWV\JGRPPHQXGYLNOHGHVLJIUDPLGWHQDI PDMSnHQU NNHORNDOLWHWHUPHQDWDQJUHEHQH IRUEOHYIRUKROGVYLVODYHWLOPRGHUDWH

6HSWRULD6HSWRULDWULWLFL$QJUHEDIKYHGH JUnSOHWIRUEOHYPRGHUDWHVHOYRPGHUI¡UVWSn Y NVWV VRQHQNRPNUDIWLJHDQJUHEVRPI¡OJH DIPHJHQQHGE¡ULPDMRJI¡UVWHKDOYGHODIMXQL PnQHG,V UPHJHWVWRUHQHGE¡UVP QJGHUGHQ PDMJDYDQOHGQLQJWLONUDIWLJHDQJUHE Sn¡YHUVWHEODGRPNULQJGHQMXQL±XJHU HIWHU6LGVWHKDOYGHODIMXQLRJMXOLYDUGRJIRU KROGVYLVW¡URJG PSHGHGHQYLGHUHXGYLNOLQJ DIVHSWRULDVRPVnOHGHVHQGWHPHGNXQDWJLYH ODYHWLOPRGHUDWHDQJUHESnGH¡YHUVWHEODGH ,RJYDUGHUKHQKROGVYLVRJ DQJUHESnIDQHEODGHWSnYVLYDUGHWWH QLYHDXSn

*XOUXVW3XFFLQLDVWULLIRUPLV'HUIRUHNRP Q VWHQ LJHQ DQJUHE DI JXOUXVW L IRUV¡JHQH L .XQ L %DOWLPRU KYRU GHU EOHY VPLWWHW NXQVWLJ NRP GHU DQJUHE 6LGVW Sn V VRQHQ NRPGHUEHJU QVHGHDQJUHEL$XGLRJ2DNOH\

%UXQUXVW3XFFLQLDUHFRQGLWD'HUIRUHNRP NXQPHJHWInPDUNHUPHGVHQHDQJUHEDIEUXQ UXVWKYLONHWYDULRYHUHQVVWHPPHOVHPHGGDWD IUDUHJLVWUHULQJVQHWWHW

+YHGHEODGSOHW'UHFKVOHUDWULWLFLUHSHQWLV

$QJUHEDIKYHGHEODGSOHWRSWUnGWHIUDPLGWHQ DIDSULOLPDUNHUPHGIRUIUXJWDIKYHGHRJUH GXFHUHWMRUGEHKDQGOLQJ$QJUHEHQHXGYLNOHGH VLJIRUKROGVYLVWNUDIWLJW,VOXWQLQJHQDIMXQLRJ I¡UVWHKDOYGHODIMXOLXGYLNOHGHDQJUHEHQHVLJ NUDIWLJWLIRUV¡JHQHRJJDYJRGHPXOLJKHGHU IRUDWYXUGHUHPLGOHUQHVHIIHNWHU

)XVDULXPLDNVHW'HUEOHYQ VWHQLNNHIXQ GHWV\QOLJHDQJUHEDIDNVIXVDULXPLRJGH PnOWHLQGKROGDIP\NRWRNVLQHUIRUEOHYRJVnSn HWODYWQLYHDX*HQHUHOWYDUGHUW¡UWYHMUXQGHU EORPVWULQJHQKYLONHWUHGXFHUHGHULVLNRHQIRU DQJUHE,IRUV¡JSn)ODNNHEMHUJEOHYGHUNXQ VWLJWLQRNXOHUHWPHG)XVDULXP+HUEOHYGHU GHVXGHQYDQGHWNXQVWLJWKYLONHWVWLPXOHUHGH WLOEHW\GHOLJHDQJUHEGHUJDYJRGHPXOLJKHGHU IRUDWGLIIHUHQWLHUHHIIHNWHQDIIRUVNHOOLJHIXQ JLFLGHURJVRUWHU

.Q NNHIRGV\JH3VHXGRFHUFRVSRUHOOD KHU SRWULFKRLGHV$QJUHEHQHEOHYNXQYXUGHUHWL HWSDUHQNHOWHIRUV¡J'HUIRUHNRPPRGHUDWH DQJUHE L GLVVH IRUV¡J, IXQJLFLGIRUV¡J VRP EOHYXQGHUV¡JWIRUDQJUHEEOHYGHULNNHIXQ GHWNODUHIRUVNHOOHLPHOOHPEHKDQGOHGHRJXEH KDQGOHGHOHG

*ROGIRGV\JH *DHXPDQQRP\FHV JUDPLQLV

$QJUHEHQHDIJROGIRGV\JHYDU\GHUVWEHJU Q VHWL'HUYDULNNHIRUV¡JPHGNHPLVNEH N PSHOVHDIJROGIRGV\JHL

(14)

7ULWLFDOH

*XOUXVW3XFFLQLDVWULLIRUPLV'HUIRUHNRP LJHQLNUDIWLJHDQJUHEDIJXOUXVWLWULWLFDOH IRUV¡JHQH6HOYRPGHWYDUHQNROGYLQWHUVn RYHUOHYHGHVPLWVWRIYLQWHUHQRJVDWWHLIRUnUHW DWWHUJDQJLV\JGRPVXGYLNOLQJHQ,V UYDUGHU NUDIWLJHDQJUHELDNVHW)RUV¡JHQHPHGWULWLFDOH JDYJRGHPXOLJKHGHUIRUDWWHVWHIXQJLFLGHUVHI IHNWLYLWHWRYHUIRUGHQQHV\JGRP

9LQWHUE\J

%\JPHOGXJ %OXPHULD JUDPLQLV 'HU YDU L NUDIWLJHDQJUHEDIPHOGXJVRPJDYJRGH PXOLJKHGHUIRUDWGLIIHUHQWLHUHHIIHNWHQDIGH IRUVNHOOLJH IXQJLFLGHU )UD UHJLVWUHULQJVQHWWHW EOHYGHUOLJHOHGHVREVHUYHUHWGHNUDIWLJVWHDQ JUHEDIPHOGXJLGHVLGVWHnU$OOHGHVRUWHU VRPYDUYDOJWWLOIRUV¡J¿NPHOGXJRJGHWJHQ QHPVQLWOLJHDQJUHESnYVYDU

%\JUXVW3XFFLQLDKRUGHLIRUHNRPNXQPHG PHJHWODYHRJVSRUDGLVNHDQJUHEL'HWWH YDULVOnHQGHNRQWUDVWWLOGHVHQHUHnUVNUDIWLJH DQJUHE'HQNROGHYLQWHURJGHWVHQHN¡OLJH IRUnUKDUY UHWKRYHGnUVDJHQWLOGHODYHDQ JUHE0HQVDQJUHEHQHLLJHQQHPVQLWYDU SnYVYDUDQJUHEHWNXQSnL GHHQHVWHIRUV¡JKYRUDQJUHEEOHYREVHUYHUHW L

6NROGSOHW5K\QFKRVSRULXPVHFDOLV, YDUGHUEHW\GHOLJHDQJUHEDIVNROGSOHWVRPYDU VWLPXOHUHWDIGHIXJWLJHIRUKROGXQGHUVWU N QLQJVY NVWHQLPDMPnQHG,V ULVRUWHQ:LQ PDOW YDU GHU JRGH PXOLJKHGHU IRU DW VNHOQH PLGOHUQHVHIIHNW,JHQQHPVQLWYDUGHUDQ JUHELGHQQHVRUWSnYV

%\JEODGSOHW'UHFKVOHUDWHUHVIRUHNRPOLJH OHGHVPHGNUDIWLJHDQJUHELÀHUHVRUWHUL ,V U3HOLFDQ¿NNUDIWLJHDQJUHEVRPJDYJRGH PXOLJKHGHUIRUDWDGVNLOOHPLGOHUQHVHIIHNWHU ,JHQQHPVQLWYDUGHUDQJUHELIRUV¡JL 3HOLFDQSnYV

5DPXODULD5DPXODULDFROORF\JQL'HUYDU LEHW\GHOLJHDQJUHEDI5DPXODULDLYLQWHU

E\JVRPXGYLNOHGHVLJIUDYV'HUYDUJRGH PXOLJKHGHUIRUDWVNHOQHPLGOHUQHVHIIHNW,V U YDUGHUJRGHPXOLJKHGHUIRUDWVHV\JGRPPHQ L3HOLFDQVRPLJHQQHPVQLWDIIRUV¡JKDYGH DQJUHESnYV

9nUE\J

%\JPHOGXJ %OXPHULD JUDPLQLV$QJUHEH QHLYDUODYHWLOPRGHUDWH,V ULVRUWHUQH 3RZHURJ9DUEHUJEOHYGHUREVHUYHUHWDQJUHE LIRUV¡JHQH$QJUHEHQHIRUEOHYGRJJHQHUHOW IRUKROGVYLVODYHRJLJHQQHPVQLWDIIRUV¡JHQH YDUGHUXQGHUDQJUHESnYV

%\JEODGSOHW'UHFKVOHUDWHUHVRSWUnGWHPHG ODYHRJXEHW\GHOLJHDQJUHE$IUHJLVWHULQJVQHW WHWIUHPJLNGHWRJVnDWDQJUHEHQHYDUV UGHOHV ODYHL

6NROGSOHW 5K\QFKRVSRULXP VHFDOLV RS WUnGWHPHGPRGHUDWHRJSOHWYLVHDQJUHELEOD 4XHQFKRJ+HQOH\,YLVVHPDUNHUYDUGHUNUDI WLJHDQJUHEPHQUHJLVWUHULQJVQHWWHWYLVWHGRJ JHQHUHOWHWIRUKROGVYLVWODYWRJVHQWDQJUHE

%\JUXVW3XFFLQLDKRUGHLRSWUnGWHPHGPR GHUDWHDQJUHEL$QJUHEHQHYDUGRJPHUH XGEUHGWHHQGLYLQWHUE\JRJLV UL4XHQFKYDU GHWPXOLJWDWYXUGHUHPLGOHUQHVHIIHNWSnV\J GRPPHQ,JHQQHPVQLWDIIRUV¡JHQL4XHQFK YDUGHUDQJUHESnYV

5DPXODULD 5DPXODULD FROORF\JQL 'HU EOHYNXQIXQGHWODYHDQJUHEDI5DPXODULDLIRU V¡JHQH6HOYLVRUWHQ4XHQFKVRPHUNHQGWIRU DWY UHPRGWDJHOLJIRUEOHYDQJUHEHQHODYH +DYUH

+DYUHSOHWEDNWHULRVH

,GHVHQHUHnUHUGHUVHWHQU NNHDQJUHEDIKDY UHSOHWEDNWHULRVH 'HQQH EDNWHULHV\JGRP NDQ VSUHGHVPHGXGV GHQRJXGYLNOHUVLJNUDIWLJVW XQGHUIXJWLJHIRUKROG(QU NNHXGV GVSDUWLHU IUD6YHULJHEOHYXGVnHWLRJHIWHUI¡OJHQ GHVSU¡MWHWPHGIXQJLFLGHUIRUDWVHRPLV U

&RPHW NXQQH ELGUDJH WLO LQGXFHUHW UHVLVWHQV 'HUIRUHNRPODYHDQJUHELIRUV¡JHWPHQLQJHQ

(15)

VLNUH IRUVNHOOH LPHOOHP EHKDQGOHGH RJ XEH KDQGOHGH OHG +DYUHSOHWEDNWHULRVH IRUHNRP RJVnUHWXGEUHGWLÀHUHVRUWHULREVHUYDWLRQV SDUFHOOHUQH

0HUXGE\WWHUIRUIXQJLFLGEHN PSHOVHL NRUQ*HQHUHOWYDUK¡VWXGE\WWHUQHLQ UGHWQRU PDOHKYLONHWGRJIRULV UKYHGHYDUY VHQWOLJW XQGHU UHNRUGQLYHDXHUQH IUD RJ , IRUV¡JHQHOnGHW\SLVNHXGE\WWHUDIKYHGHSn RPNULQJKNJKDLYLQWHUE\JY VHQWOLJ K¡MHUHRJSnRPNULQJKNJKD,YnUE\JOn QLYHDXHWRPNULQJKNJKD

'H ODYHUH XGE\WWHU WLOVNULYHV GHQ UHODWLYW KnUGHYLQWHURJGHQQRJHWW\QGHSODQWHEHVWDQG LÀHUHKYHGHPDUNHU

0HUXGE\WWHUQH IRU VYDPSHEHN PSHOVH L KYHGHYDUSnQLYHDXPHGGHVLGVWHY NVW V VRQHU RJ YDU KRYHGVDJHOLJW HQ UHVSRQV Sn EHN PSHOVHDIVHSWRULD,HQNHOWHIRUV¡JPHG EHW\GHOLJH JXOUXVWDQJUHE YDU GHU VW¡UUH PHU XGE\WWHU/6'Y UGLHUQHYDUJHQHUHOWK¡MHRJ YLGQHURPUHODWLYWW\QGHRJQRJHWXHQVPDUNHU

0HUXGE\WWHUQHLEnGHYnUE\JRJYLQWHUE\J YDULJHQQHPVQLWRPNULQJKNJKDKYLONHWHU HWPHJHWJHQQHPVQLWOLJWQLYHDXVHWLIRUKROGWLO WLGOLJHUHnU(QGHOIRUV¡JPHGNUDIWLJHDQJUHE DIE\JUXVWLVRUWHQ4XHQFKJDYGRJY VHQWOLJ

K¡MHUHPHUXGE\WWHUSnPHOOHPRJKNJ KD

0DMV'HUIRUHNRPSnGHWRIRUV¡JVORNDOLWHWHUDQJUHE DI PDMVEODGSOHW 'UHFKVOHUD WXUFLFD PHQV DQJUHEDI¡MHSOHW.DEDWLHOOD]HDHKHOWXGH EOHY%HJJHV\JGRPPHXGYLNOHUVLJW\SLVNIUD SODQWHUHVWHULEXQGHQDIDIJU¡GHQVWDPPHQGH IUDVLGVWHnUVDIJU¡GH'HUIRUHNRPLNNHNODUH DQJUHEDI)XVDULXPLNROEHUQHPHQNHUQHSU¡

YHUIUD)ODNNHEMHUJYLVWHPHJHWK¡MHY UGLHU DI'21KYLONHWPnVNHKRYHGVDJHOLJWVN\OGHV HQVHQK¡VWPLGWQRYHPEHU'HUYDUSRVLWLYH PHUXGE\WWHUIRUEHN PSHOVHDIPDMVEODGSOHW PHQNXQLHWDIGHIRUV¡JYDUGHUWDOHRPVLJ QL¿NDQWHPHUXGE\WWHU

)U¡JU V

,nUHWVIRUV¡JPHGV\JGRPPHLIU¡JU VIRUH NRP KRYHGVDJHOLJW EODGSOHW L VWUDQGVYLQJHO 3\UHQRSKRUD VSS ODYH DQJUHE DI NURQUXVW 3XFFLQLD FRURQDWD L UDMJU V RJ VW UNH DQ JUHEDI0DVWLJRVSRULXPLKXQGHJU V,O¡EHW DIVRPPHUHQRJLJHQLHIWHUnUHWXGYLN OHGHGHUVLJNUDIWLJHDQJUHEDIJXOUXVWLPDQJH HQJUDSJU VPDUNHU.XQLKXQGHJU VIRUV¡JHW EOHYGHUK¡VWHWVWRUHRJVLJQL¿NDQWHPHUXGE\W WHUIRUEHN PSHOVHDIEODGVYDPSH

+DYUHSOHWEDNWHULRVH YDU XGEUHGWLHQU NNHKDYUH VRUWHU

(16)

.DUWRÀHU

.DUWRIIHOVNLPPHO , NXQQH GHU LNNH NRQVWDWHUHV MRUGEnUHQW DQJUHE L GHW RRVSRUH VPLWWHGHIHOWWLOWURGVIRULQWHQVLYYDQGLQJYHG NDUWRIIHOSODQWHUQHVIUHPVSLULQJ'HI¡UVWHDQ JUHEDINDUWRIIHOVNLPPHOLIRUV¡JVPDUNHQEOHY VHW L EHJ\QGHOVHQ DI MXOL )RUV¡JVSDUFHOOHU L VRUWHQ%LQWMHEOHYVPLWWHWNXQVWLJWPHGVSRUDQ JLHRSO¡VQLQJGHQMXQLRJGHQMXOLHIWHU GDJHYDUGHUNUDIWLJXGYLNOLQJDINDUWRIIHO VNLPPHOLGHVPLWWHGHSDUFHOOHU+HUIUDVSUHGWH VPLWWHQVLJWLOGHQ UOLJJHQGHXVPLWWHGHIRU V¡JVSDUFHOOHUPHG%LQWMHRJGHI¡UVWHDQJUHE NXQQHNRQVWDWHUHVGHQMXOL,GHQ¡YULJH IRUV¡JVPDUNEOHYGHUXGEUDJWVPLWWHLVPLWWH U NNHUQHGHQMXOLRJDOOHUHGHGHQMXOL HIWHUGDJHNXQQHGHI¡UVWHDQJUHEVHVSn GHSODQWHUGHUYDUEOHYHWVPLWWHW+HUIUDVSUHG WHVNLPPHOHQVLJWLOGH¡YULJHSDUFHOOHURJGH I¡UVWH DQJUHE L XEHKDQGOHGH IRUV¡JVSDUFHO OHULIRUV¡JVPDUNHQEOHYVHWRPNULQJGHQ MXOL'HUXGYLNOHGHVLJHIWHUI¡OJHQGHHWNUDIWLJW DQJUHEGHVLGVWHXJHUDIMXOLLVRUWHUQH.XUDV

RJ.DUQLFR,VRUWHQ6WD\HUNRPDQJUHEHWOLGW KXUWLJHUHLJDQJPHQIRUO¡EVHQHUHVRPLGH WRDQGUHVRUWHU'HXEHKDQGOHGHSDUFHOOHUYDU VWRUWVHWQHGYLVQHGHVRPI¡OJHDIVNLPPHODQ JUHEFDHQPnQHGHIWHUDWGHI¡UVWHDQJUHEEOHY NRQVWDWHUHW'HWEHP UNHVDWVNLPPHOXGYLN OLQJHQ L VRUWHQ .XUDV Sn )ODNNHEMHUJ IRUO¡E Q VWHQVRPLVRUWHUQH.DUQLFRRJ6WD\HUIUD EHJ\QGHOVHQDIDXJXVW

'HUEOHYVPLWWHWPHGNDUWRIIHOVNLPPHOSn -\QGHYDGRJLIRUV¡JVPDUNHQYHG6XQGVGHQ MXOLRJVRPSn)ODNNHEMHUJEOHYGHI¡UVWHDQ JUHELIRUV¡JVSDUFHOOHUQHVHWRPNULQJGHQ MXOL$QJUHEDIVNLPPHOLXEHKDQGOHGHNDUWRI OHUXGYLNOHGHVLJEHJJHVWHGHUSnVDPPHPnGH VRPSn)ODNNHEMHUJ,IRUV¡JVPDUNHQSn'URQ QLQJOXQGKYRUGHULNNHEOHYVPLWWHWPHGVNLP PHOEOHYGHI¡UVWHDQJUHEI¡UVWVHWLEHJ\QGHO VHQDIDXJXVWRJVNLPPHOXGYLNOLQJHQYDU XJHUVHQHUHHQGSn)ODNNHEMHUJ-\QGHYDGRJ 6XQGV

'HI¡UVWHDQJUHEDINDUWRIIHOEODGSOHW$O WHUQDULDVRODQL$DOWHUQDWDEOHYVHWRPNULQJ 7DEHO0HUXGE\WWHKNJKDIRUEHN PSHOVHLIXQJLFLGIRUV¡J7\SLVNHPHUXGE\WWHUIUDVWDQGDUG OHGVRPHULQGLNDWRUHUIRUGHWSRWHQWLHOOHPHUXGE\WWH7DOOHQHLSDUHQWHVG NNHURYHUDQWDOOHWDI IRUV¡J7DOOHQHIUDVWDPPHUIUD/&VRJ'-)VIRUV¡JPHGIXQJLFLGHU

cU 9LQWHUKYHGH 9nUE\J 9LQWHUE\J

(17)

MXOL Sn )ODNNHEMHUJ RJ -\QGHYDG RJ IUD VOXWQLQJHQDIMXOLLIRUV¡JVPDUNHQSn6XQGV

$QJUHEXGYLNOHGHVLJPRGHUDWRJLVHSWHPEHU YDUGHUFDDQJUHESn)ODNNHEMHUJL$O WHUQDULDXEHKDQGOHGH SDUFHOOHU VSU¡MWHW PHG 5DQPDQ 3n 6XQGV YDU DQJUHEHQH RPNULQJ VLGVWSnV VRQHQRJDQJUHEHQHYDUJHQH UHOWPLQGUHHQGL

5DSV,IRUHNRPGHUNXQVYDJHDQJUHEDIVWRU NQROGHW NQROGE JHUVYDPS 6FOHURWLQLD VFOHURWLRUXP'HWJMDOGWEnGHSn)ODNNHEMHUJ

RJLIRUV¡JVPDUNHUDQODJWKRVUDSVDYOHUH3n )ODNNHEMHUJYDUGHUXGODJWVPLWVWRILPDUNHQ PHQDQJUHEVORJGHVY UUHLNNHDQPXOLJYLV VRP I¡OJH DI W¡UUH IRUKROG I¡U EORPVWULQJ DI UDSVSODQWHUQH'HUEOHYVHWPRGHUDWHDQJUHE DI3KRPDURGKDOVUnG/HSWRVSKDHULDPDFX ODQV PHQ GHW YDU KRYHGVDJHOLJW VHNXQG U VPLWWHIUDPDUNHQRJLNNHVRPI¡OJHDIDQJUHE LHIWHUnUHW$QDO\VHUDIURGKDOVHQIUDHQODQJ U NNHVRUWHUYLVWNXQODYHDQJUHEVRPI¡OJHDI HIWHUnUVVPLWWH $QJUHE DIVNXOSHVYDPS$O WHUQDULDEUDVVLFDHYDUJHQHUHOWPHJHWODYHL IRUV¡JHQH

$QJUHEDI3KRPDSnUDSVVW QJOHU

(18)

,QGOHGQLQJ

,GHWWHDIVQLWHUUHGHJMRUWIRUIRUV¡JVRPHUXG I¡UWLPHGIXQJLFLGHULNRUQ+RYHGUHVXO WDWHUQHIUDPLGOHUQHVHIIHNWHUPHGWDJHW'HU HUPHGWDJHWUHVXOWDWHUIUDSODQHUVRPGDQQHU EDJJUXQGIRUQ\HJRGNHQGHOVHUVnYHOVRPUH VXOWDWHUIUDIRUV¡JVSODQHUGHUKDUWLOIRUPnODW WHVWHPHUHVWUDWHJLVNHRJDQYHQGHOVHVRULHQWH UHGHVS¡UJVPnO

,IRUO QJHOVHDIHIIHNWUHVXOWDWHUQHEULQJHV QRJOHInNRPPHQWDUHUGHUHUUHOHYDQWHIRUGH HQNHOWHSODQHU(QOLVWHRYHUGHWHVWHGHPLGOHUV DNWLYVWRIIHU IUHPJnU DI NHPLNDOLHRYHUVLJWHQ EDJLERJHQ

0HWRGH

$OOH DISU¡YQLQJVIRUV¡JHQH HU XGI¡UW VRP PDUNIRUV¡J XGVWDWLRQHUHW KRV ODQGP QG HO OHU Sn IRUV¡JVVWDWLRQHU )RUV¡JHQH KDU Y UHW SODFHUHWSn6M OODQGYHG+RUVHQVRJL6¡QGHU M\OODQG)RUV¡JHQHHUXGI¡UWVRPEORNIRUV¡J PHGWLOI OGLJSDUFHOIRUGHOLQJRJJHQWDJHOVHU 3DUFHOVW¡UUHOVHQYDULHUHUIUDP)RUV¡

JHQHHUV¡JWSODFHUHWLIRUVNHOOLJHNRUQVRUWHU GHUUHSU VHQWHUHUIRUVNHOOLJJUDGDIV\JGRPV PRGWDJHOLJKHG*HQHUHOWWLOVWU EHVGHUVLWXDWL RQHUKYRUPDQNDQIRUYHQWHEHW\GHOLJHDQJUHE IRUEHGVWPXOLJWDWInPLGOHUQHVHIIHNWEHO\VW 6SU¡MWQLQJHUQH HU XGI¡UW PHG KnQGEHWMHQWH ERPVSU¡MWHU RJ VHOYN¡UHQGH SDUFHOVSU¡MWHU GUHYHWDIDWPRVI ULVNWU\NOXIWHOOHUNY OVWRI WU\NOXIW 6SU¡MWQLQJHU HU IRUHWDJHW PHG OYDQGSUKDRJHWG\VHWU\NSnEDU

6\JGRPVDQJUHEHUEHG¡PWPHGFDGD JHVLQWHUYDOLY NVWV VRQHQ3URFHQWJU¡QQH SODQWHGHOHDQJUHEHWDIGHHQNHOWHV\JGRPPH HU EHVWHPW .XQ GH V\JGRPVEHVWHPPHOVHU VRPYLVHUGHVW¡UVWHIRUVNHOOHLPHOOHPPLGOHU HUPHGWDJHW

)RUV¡JHQH HU K¡VWHW RJ NHUQHXGE\WWHW HU NRUULJHUHWWLOYDQG'HUHUIRUHWDJHWNYD OLWHWVEHVWHPPHOVHU KHNWROLWHUY JW SURWHLQ LQGKROGVWLYHOVHPPSnDOOHNHUQHSU¡YHURJ WXVLQGNRUQVY JWHQHUEHVWHPWLDOOHIRUV¡JHQH RJLYnUE\JHUGHUXGI¡UWVW¡UUHOVHVVRUWHULQJDI NHUQHUQH9HGRSJ¡UHOVHUQHHUGHUEHUHJQHWHQ /6'Y UGLHOOHUOHGGHQHHUP UNHWPHGHW ERJVWDY/HGPHGVDPPHERJVWDYHULNNHVLJ QL¿NDQWIRUVNHOOLJH

+YRU GHU HU XGUHJQHW QHWWRXGE\WWH HU EUXJWNHPLNDOLHSULVHUM YQI¡Uµ2YHUVLJWRYHU /DQGVIRUV¡JHQH¶NUSUXGEULQJHOVH RJNUSUKNJNRUQ

)RUV¡JVHQKHGHQL)ODNNHEMHUJHUDQHUNHQGW WLODWXGI¡UH*(3IRUV¡J

3HVWLFLGDISU¡YQLQJ

,,

%HN PSHOVHDIVYDPSHV\JGRPPHLNRUQ

/LVH1LVWUXS-¡UJHQVHQ+HOHQH6DOWRIW.ULVWMDQVHQ 6LGVHO.LUNHJDDUG

)RUDWVLNUHDQJUHEDIJXOUXVWLIRUV¡JHQHEOL YHUGHUVPLWWHWYHGDWVSUHGHVSRUHUIUDSODQWHU PHGDQJUHE

(19)

(QU NNHQ\HIXQJLFLGHUHUXQGHUXGYLNOLQJ 0LGOHUQHKDUYLVWHWEHW\GHOLJWSRWHQWLDOHIRU DWIRUEHGUHRJVW\UNHV\JGRPVEHN PSHOVHQL EODNRUQ

'HQQ\HJUXSSHDNWLYVWRIIHUEHWHJQHVHQ WHQ 6'+,¶HU VXFFLQDWH GHK\GURJHQDVH LQKL ELWRUHU HOOHU FDUER[DPLGHU %RVFDOLG HU GHW I¡UVWHDIGLVVHPLGOHUVRPEOHYJRGNHQGWIRU nUVLGHQRJEODLQGJnULSURGXNWHW%HOO)¡O JHQGHQ\H6'+,¶HUKDUY UHWLDISU¡YQLQJL 'DQPDUNEL[DIHQ%D\HULVRS\UD]DP6\Q JHQWDSHQWKLRS\UDG'XSRQWRJÀX[DS\UR [DG %$6) 6RP XGJDQJVSXQNW IRUYHQWHV PLGOHUQHNXQDWEOLYHJRGNHQGWLEODQGLQJPHG UHOHYDQWHEODQGLQJVSDUWQHUH'HWWHVNHUIRUDW PLQGVNHULVLNRHQIRUXGYLNOLQJDIIXQJLFLGUH VLVWHQV

9LUNHPHNDQLVPHU

*UXSSHQDI6'+,IXQJLFLGHUEOHYXGYLNOHWIRU PHUHHQGnUVLGHQ6'+,PLGOHUQHKDUHQ VSHFL¿NYLUNHPHNDQLVPHRJKDUGHUHV´WDUJHW SRLQW´LVYDPSHFHOOHUQHVPLWRFKRQGULHUFRP SOH[,,)RUVW\UUHOVHQDIHOHNWURQWUDQVSRUWHQ

L PLWRFKRQGULHUQH SnYLUNHU FHOOHUQHV HQHUJL SURGXNWLRQGHULJHQSnYLUNHUSURGXNWLRQHQDI EODDPLQRV\UHRJOLSLGHULFHOOHUQH2JVnVWUR ELOXULQHUQHYLUNHULQGLPLWRFKRQGULHUQHPHQ SnHWDQGHWVWHG'HUHUVnOHGHVLNNHNU\GVUHVL VWHQVLPHOOHPGHWRJUXSSHUDIPLGOHU6'+, PLGOHUQHHUJHQHUHOWV\VWHPLVNHRJRSWDJHVL EODGHQHKYLONHWJLYHUPXOLJKHGHUIRUDWRSQn EnGHHQSU YHQWLYRJHQNXUDWLYEHN PSHOVH DIEODGV\JGRPPH

'DLNNHDOOH6'+,PLGOHUQHHUWLOJ QJHOL JHDOHQHHUGHWVY UWNRQNUHWDWYXUGHUHDNWLY VWRIIHUQHVSRWHQWLDOH,O\NNHGHVGHWGRJ DWDISU¡YHDIGHQ\HUHQHDNWLYVWRIIHUPRG V\JGRPPHLKYHGHWDEHO%L[DIHQEOHYNXQ WHVWHWLEODQGLQJPHGSURWKLRFRQD]RO

5HVLVWHQVULVLNR

6HOYRP6'+,JUXSSHQKDUY UHWNHQGWLPDQ JHnUKDUGHUSnJUXQGDIEHJU QVHWDQYHQGHOVH NXQY UHWInNHQGWHWLOI OGHDIUHVLVWHQVUXVWL NU\VDQWHPXPRJQ¡JHQEUDQGLE\J0HQVRP GHWHUWLOI OGHWIRUGHÀHVWHPLGOHUPHGVSH FL¿NYLUNHPHNDQLVPHHUGHUHQEHW\GHOLJUL

6'+,¶HUHOOHUFDUER[DPLGHUHQQ\JUXSSHIXQJLFLGHU

1DYQ $NWLYVWRIP QJGHSUOLWHU 0DUNGRVLV )LUPD

%HOO JERVFDOLGJHSR[LFRQD]RO %$6)

%$6 JERVFDOLGJHSR[LFRQD]RO %$6)

%$6 JERVFDOLGJHSR[LFRQD]ROJS\UDFORVWURELQ %$6)

%$<$YLDWRU JEL[DIHQJSURWKLRFRQD]RO %D\HU

%$< JEL[DIHQJSURWKLRFRQD]ROJWHEXFRQD]RO %D\HU

%$<) JEL[DIHQJSURWKLRFRQD]RO %D\HU

$2

%$6 ÀX[DS\UR[DG;HPLXP %$6)

%$6 JÀX[DS\UR[DGJHSR[LFRQD]RO %$6) 9-%RQWLPD $& JLVRS\UD]DPF\SURGLQLO 6\QJHQWD

,=0 JLVRS\UD]DP 6\QJHQWD

7DEHO/LVWHRYHUSURGXNWHUPHG6'+,SURGXNWHUVRPKDUY UHWLDISU¡YQLQJ

(20)

%HKDQGOLQJSnY NVWVWDGLH PHOGXJ

YV '75

YV

¡YUHEODGH

VHSWRULD YV

¡YUHEODGH

JU¡QW EODG YV

8GE\WWHRJ PHUXGE\WWH KNJKD

8GE\WWHRJ PHUXGE\WWH KNJKD

YV OKD )VJ )VJ )VJ )VJ )VJ

8EHKDQGOHW D D F

$2 E E E

%$< G E D

,=0 F E DE

%$6) E E DE

2SXV E E DE

$QWDOIRUV¡J

/6'

7DEHO6DPPHQOLJQLQJDI6'+,¶HUVHIIHNWHUSnEHN PSHOVHDIKYHGHV\JGRPPH'HUHUDQ YHQGWIXOGGRVHULQJRJEHVSU¡MWHWSnYVIRUV¡J

%HKDQGOLQJSnY NVWVWDGLH PHOGXJ

YV E\JUXVW

YV E\JEODG SOHW YV

UDPX ODULD YV

VNROG SOHW YV

8GE\WWH RJPHU XGE\WWH

1HWWRPHU XGE\WWH

KNJKD

YV OKD

8EHKDQGOHW

%HOO&RPHW

$SURDFK)ROLFXU

9-

$QWDOIRUV¡J

/6'

7DEHO6DPPHQOLJQLQJDI6'+,¶HUVHIIHNWHUSnEHN PSHOVHDIE\JV\JGRPPH'HUHUDQYHQGW KDOYGRVHULQJRJVSU¡MWHWSnYVIRUV¡J

)LJXU0ROHN\OHUDI6'+, 6'+,IXQJLFLGHU

(21)

VLNRIRUXGYLNOLQJDIIXQJLFLGUHVLVWHQVYHGXG EUHGWDQYHQGHOVH5LVLNRHQNDUDNWHULVHUHVVRP PHGLXPWLOK¡MIRUJUXSSHQDI6'+,¶HU6LGHQ LQWURGXNWLRQHQDIERVFDOLGHUÀHUHWLOI OGHDI UHVLVWHQV GXNNHW RS L XGODQGHW LQGHQ IRU KD YHEUXJVRPUnGHWEODJUnVNLPPHOLMRUGE U PHOGXJLDJXUNHUDOWHUQDULDLSLVWDFKQ¡GGHU 0LQGVWIRUVNHOOLJH´WDUJHWVLWHVPXWDWLRQHU´

VRPHUnUVDJHQWLOGHRSVWnHGHUHVLVWHQVSUREOH PHUHUEHVNUHYHW0RQLWHULQJIRUUHVLVWHQVKRV ÀHUHDNWXHOOHNRUQV\JGRPPHKDULQGWLOYLGHUH KHOGLJYLVLNNHYLVWQRJHQWHJQSn QGULQJHU 5HVXOWDWHUPHG6'+,HU

'HKYHGHIRUV¡JYLVWHDW6'+,PLGOHUQHKDU JLYHWHQJRGEHN PSHOVHDIVHSWRULD(IIHNWHU QHYDUEHGUHHOOHUSnQLYHDXPHG2SXV%$6 )YDUGHQPHVWHIIHNWLYHWLOEHN PSHO VHDIVHSWRULD,GHWHQHIRUV¡JIRUHNRPNUDI WLJHDQJUHEDIKYHGHEODGSOHW'752YHUIRU GHQQHV\JGRPYDU,=0,VRS\UD]DQHOOHU

%$<PHVWHIIHNWLYH

0HUXGE\WWHUQHYDUVLJQL¿NDQWHLIRUKROGWLO XEHKDQGOHWRJKHUDGVNLOWH6'+,SURGXNWHUQH VLJLNNHNODUWIUD2SXV

6RP HNVHPSHO Sn UHVXOWDWHU PHG GH Q\H 6'+,¶HUHUGHULYLQWHUE\JXGI¡UWIRUV¡JL SHULRGHQKYRU9-%RQWLPD KDU Y UHW VDPPHQOLJQHW PHG %HOO &RPHW RJ$SURDFK)ROLFXU6RPGHWIUHPJnUKDU SURGXNWHWJLYHWJRGHHIIHNWHURJVDPPHQOLJ QHOLJHPHUXGE\WWHU$QGUHUHVXOWDWHUPHGQ\H 6'+,¶HULYLQWHUE\JVHVRJVnLWDEHORJL YnUE\JLWDEHORJ

6HSWRULDDQJUHEHWEODGKHOWI\OGWPHGS\NQLGHU

¡YHUVWQHGHUVWHWVXQGWEODG

(22)

%$6RJ%$6

7RQ\HIRUPXOHULQJHUDIIXQJLFLGHUVRPEHVWnU DIERVFDOLGEODQGHWPHGKHQKROGVYLVHSR[LFR DQ]RO%$6HOOHUHSR[LFRQD]ROS\UDFOR VWURELQ%$6KDUY UHWDISU¡YHWLEH JU QVHWXGVWU NQLQJLRJLVW¡UUHRPIDQJ LKYRUIRUV¡JEOHYXGI¡UWLEnGHKYHGH E\J KDYUH RJ WULWLFDOH 5HVXOWDWHUQH LQGJnU VRPHQGHODIGRNXPHQWDWLRQHQLIRUELQGHOVH PHGJRGNHQGHOVHQ5HVXOWDWHWDIDISU¡YQLQJHQ KDUYLVWJRGHHIIHNWHUSnGHYLJWLJVWHV\JGRP PHLKHQKROGVYLVKYHGHRJE\J

%$6JHSR[LFRQD]ROJERVFDOLGO

QRUPDOGRVHOKD

%$6JHSR[LFRQD]ROJERVFDOLG JS\UDFORVWURELQOQRUPDOGRVHOKD 1nUGHSURGXNWHUHUDISU¡YHWLIXOGGRVLVLQG JnUGHUJHSR[LFRQD]ROPHUHHQGL%HOO 9LQWHUKYHGH5HVXOWDWHUQHLKYHGHYLVWHULJWLJ JRGEHN PSHOVHDIVHSWRULDRJJXOUXVWOLJH VRPGHUYDUHQW\GHOLJIRUO QJHOVHDIDIJU¡GHQV JU¡QKHGRJVLJQL¿NDQWHPHUXGE\WWHUWDEHO RJ¿JXU%HJJHGHWRQ\HIRUPXOHULQJHUYDU SnQLYHDXPHGHOOHURYHUOHJQHLHIIHNWHUYXUGH UHWLIRUKROGWLO%HOO

$ISU¡YQLQJDIQ\HIXQJLFLGHU

7DEHO%HN PSHOVHDIVHSWRULDRJPHOGXJLKYHGHVDPWPHUXGE\WWHIRUEHN PSHOVHIRUV¡J 'HUHUVSU¡MWHWJDQJHLIRUV¡JHQH

%HKDQGOLQJRJY NVWVWDGLH VHSWRULD YV

EODG

VHSWRULD YV

EODG

PHOGXJ

YV $QWDOJU¡QQH EODGH YV

8GE\WWHRJ PHUXGE\WWH KNJKD

YV OKD

8EHKDQGOHW

%HOO [

%HOO [

%HOO [

%$6)[

%$6)[

%$6) [

%$6)[

%$6)[

%$6)[

$QWDOIRUV¡J

/6'

(23)

)LJXU%HN PSHOVHDIVHSWRULDVDPWPHUXGE\WWHHIWHUVSU¡MWQLQJHUPHG%HOO%$6RJ

%$6LKYHGHIRUV¡JIUD)RUKYHUDIGHSURGXNWHUHUWHVWHWGRVHULQJHUKHOKDOYRJ NYDUW

EHN PSHOVH

%HN PSHOVHDIVHSWRULD IDQHEODG

%HOO %$6 %$6

EHN PSHOVH

%HN PSHOVHDIVHSWRULD IDQHEODG

%HOO %$6 %$6

EHN PSHOVH

%HN PSHOVHDIVHSWRULD EODG

+NJKD

0HUXGE\WWHULKYHGH

%HOO %$6 %$6

+NJKD

0HUXGE\WWHULKYHGH

(24)

9LQWHUE\J5HVXOWDWHUQHLYLQWHUE\JYLVWHULJ

WLJJRGEHN PSHOVHDIDOOHV\JGRPPHVNROG SOHWE\JEODGSOHWPHOGXJRJ5DPXODULDWDEHO

¿JXU8GE\WWHUQHYDUK¡MHLGHIRUV¡J RJGHUYDUVLJQL¿NDQWHPHUXGE\WWHU%HJJHGH

WRQ\HIRUPXOHULQJHUYDUSnQLYHDXPHGHOOHU RYHUOHJQHLIRUKROGWLO%HOO'HUYDUW\GHOLJH PHQGRJNXQPRGHUDWHGRVHULQJVHIIHNWHUIRU DOOHSURGXNWHU

7DEHO%HN PSHOVHDIV\JGRPPHLYLQWHUE\JVDPWPHUXGE\WWHIRUEHN PSHOVHIRUV¡J 'HUHUVSU¡MWHWJDQJHLIRUV¡JHQH

%HKDQGOLQJRJY NVWVWDGLH VNROGSOHW YV EODG

E\JEODGSOHW YV EODG

PHOGXJ

YV 5DPXODULD

YV 8GE\WWHRJPHU XGE\WWHKNJKD

YV OKD

8EHKDQGOHW

%HOO [

%HOO [

%HOO [

%$6)[

%$6)[

%$6) [

%$6)[

%$6)[

%$6)[

$QWDOIRUV¡J

/6'

8EHKDQGOHWOHGPHG5DPXODULD %HKDQGOHWOHGPHG%HOO

(25)

)LJXU%HN PSHOVHDIV\JGRPPHVDPWPHUXGE\WWHUHIWHUVSU¡MWQLQJHUPHG%HOO%$6 RJ%$6LYLQWHUE\JIRUV¡JIUD)RUKYHUDIGHSURGXNWHUHUWHVWHWGRVHULQJHUKHO KDOYRJNYDUW

%HOO %$6 %$6

+NJKD

0HUXGE\WWHLYLQWHUE\J

EHN PSHOVH

%HN PSHOVHDIPHOGXJ

%HOO %$6 %$6

EHN PSHOVH

%HN PSHOVHDIPHOGXJ

%HOO %$6 %$6

EHN PSHOVH

%HN PSHOVHDI5DPXODULD

%HOO %$6 %$6

EHN PSHOVH

%HN PSHOVHDIE\JEODGSOHW

(26)

EHKDQGOLQJHU%HJJHGHWRQ\HIRUPXOHULQJHU YDUSnQLYHDXPHGHOOHURYHUOHJQHLIRUKROGWLO

%HOO'HUYDUW\GHOLJHPHQGRJNXQPRGHUDWH GRVHULQJVHIIHNWHUIRUDOOHSURGXNWHU 9nUE\J5HVXOWDWHUIUDHWIRUV¡JLYnUE\JYLVWH

JRGEHN PSHOVHDINUDIWLJHDQJUHEDIE\JUXVW RJODYHDQJUHEDIVNROGSOHWWDEHO¿JXU 0HUXGE\WWHUQHYDUK¡MHRJVLJQL¿NDQWHIRUDOOH

%HKDQGOLQJRJY NVWVWDGLH VNROGSOHW YV EODG

E\JUXVW YV

8GE\WWHRJPHU XGE\WWHKNJKD

6RUWHULQJ NHUQHVRPHUVW¡UUH

HQG

YV OKD

8EHKDQGOHW

%HOO

%HOO

%HOO

%$6)

%$6)

%$6)

%$6)

%$6)

%$6)

$QWDOIRUV¡J

/6'

7DEHO%HN PSHOVHDIV\JGRPPHLYnUE\JVDPWPHUXGE\WWHIRUEHN PSHOVHIRUV¡J 'HUHUVSU¡MWHWJDQJLIRUV¡JHW

)LJXU%HN PSHOVHDIV\JGRPPHVDPWPHUXGE\WWHHIWHUVSU¡MWQLQJPHG%HOO%$6RJ

%$6LYnUE\JIRUV¡JIUD)RUKYHUDIGHSURGXNWHUHUWHVWHWGRVHULQJHUKHOKDOYRJ NYDUW

EHN PSHOVH

%HN PSHOVHDIE\JUXVW

%HOO %$6 %$6

EHN PSHOVH

%HN PSHOVHDIE\JUXVW

+NJKD

0HUXGE\WWHLYnUE\J

%HOO %$6 %$6

+NJKD

0HUXGE\WWHLYnUE\J

(27)

+DYUHRJWULWLFDOH(WHQNHOWIRUV¡JLKDYUHEL GURJLNNHPHGQ\YLGHQGDV\JGRPVDQJUHEWR WDOWXGHEOHYIUDIRUV¡JHW'HUEOHYKHOOHULNNH K¡VWHWPHUXGE\WWHULIRUV¡JHW

,HWIRUV¡JLWULWLFDOHXGYLNOHGHGHUVLJNUDI WLJHDQJUHEDIJXOUXVW5HVXOWDWHUQHIUHPJnUDI

WDEHO$OOHWHVWHGHPLGOHUJDYJRGEHN P SHOVHDIJXOUXVWRJK¡MHVLJQL¿NDQWHPHUXGE\W WHU6HSWRULDVSSIUHPNRPVHQWSnV VRQHQ RJRJVnRYHUIRUGHQQHV\JGRPKDYGHPLGOHU QHJRGHIIHNW

7DEHO%HN PSHOVHDIV\JGRPPHLWULWLFDOHVDPWPHUXGE\WWHIRUEHN PSHOVHIRUV¡J 'HUHUVSU¡MWHWJDQJHLIRUV¡JHW

%HKDQGOLQJRJY NVWVWDGLH JXOUXVW

YV JXOUXVW

YV JXOUXVW

YV DNV

VHSWRULD YV

8GE\WWHRJ PHUXGE\WWH KNJKD

YV OKD

8EHKDQGOHW

%HOO [

%HOO [

%$<) [

%$<) [

%$<) [

%$<) [

%$6)[

%$6)[

%$6)[

%$6)[

$QWDOIRUV¡J

/6'

$QJUHEDIJXOUXVWLWULWLFDOH'HQXEHKDQGOHGHSDUFHOIUHPVWnUPLQGUHJU¡QGDDQJUHEHQHLDNVHW YDUEHW\GHOLJH

(28)

%$< %$<

7RQ\HIRUPXOHULQJHUDIIXQJLFLGHUVRPEHVWnU DI%L[DIHQEODQGHWPHGKHQKROGVYLVSURWKLR FRQD]RO%$<HOOHUSURWKLRFRQD]ROWH EXFRQD]RO%$<KDUY UHWDISU¡YHWLWR nUVIRUV¡J5HVXOWDWHUQHLQGJnUVRPHQGHODI GRNXPHQWDWLRQHQ L IRUELQGHOVH PHG JRGNHQ GHOVHQ

%$<)J%L[DIHQJSURWLRFRQD ]ROOVWDQGDUGGRVHOKDLKYHGHRJO KDLE\J

%$<)J%L[DIHQJSURWKLRFRQD ]ROJWHEXFRQD]ROOQRUPDOGRVHJO LKYHGHRJOKDLE\J

9LQWHUKYHGH5HVXOWDWHUQHLKYHGHYLVWHULJWLJ JRGEHN PSHOVHDIVHSWRULDJXOUXVWRJEUXQ UXVW OLJHVRP GHU YDU HQ W\GHOLJ IRUO QJHOVH DIDIJU¡GHQVJU¡QKHGRJVLJQL¿NDQWHPHUXG E\WWHUWDEHO¿JXU%HJJHGHWRQ\HIRU PXOHULQJHUYDURYHUOHJQHLHIIHNWHUYXUGHUHWL IRUKROGWLO3UROLQH,V UKDUGDWDIRUVHSWRULDEH N PSHOVHYLVWHQNODUWEHGUHHIIHNWVRPYLGQHU RPDWEL[DIHQKDUHQEHGUHNXUDWLYHIIHNWHQG SURWKLRFRQD]RO

7DEHO%HN PSHOVHDIVHSWRULDJXOUXVWRJEUXQUXVWLKYHGHIRUV¡J 'HUHUVSU¡MWHWJDQJHLIRUV¡JHQH

%HKDQGOLQJSnY NVWVWDGLH VHSWRULD YV EODG

VHSWRULD YV EODG

JXOUXVW

YV EUXQUXVW

YV $QWDOJU¡QQH EODGH YV

8GE\WWHRJ PHUXGE\WWH KNJKD

YV OKD

8EHKHKDQGOHW

3UROLQH [

3UROLQH [

3UROLQH [

%$<) [

%$<) [

%$<) [

%$<) [

%$<) [

%$<) [

%$<) [

%$<) [

$QWDOIRUV¡J

/6'

(29)

)LJXU%HN PSHOVHDIVHSWRULDRJJXOUXVWVDPWPHUXGE\WWHUHIWHUVSU¡MWQLQJHUPHG3UROLQH

%$<)RJ%$<)LKYHGHIRUV¡JIUDRJ)RUKYHUDIGHSURGXNWHUHUPHGWDJHW GRVHULQJHUKHOKDOYRJNYDUW

3UROLQH %$< %$<

EHN PSHOVH

%HN PSHOVHDIVHSWRULD

3UROLQH %$< %$<

0HUXGE\WWHKNJKD

0HUXGE\WWHLKYHGH

EHN PSHOVH

%HN PSHOVHDIJXOUXVW

3UROLQH %$< %$<

EHN PSHOVH

%HN PSHOVHDIJXOUXVW

(30)

9LQWHUE\J7R IRUV¡J XGI¡UW L YLQWHUE\J YDU

GRPLQHUHWDIDQJUHEDIE\JUXVWPHQRJVnE\J EODGSOHWRJODYHDQJUHEDIPHOGXJIRUHNRPL IRUV¡JHQH$OOHWHVWHGHSURGXNWHUYLVWHJRGH HIIHNWHU RJ VLJQL¿NDQWH PHUXGE\WWHU IRU EH N PSHOVHWDEHO¿JXU6\JGRPVEHN P SHOVHQYLVWHW\GHOLJHXGVODJIRUGRVLVPHQVGHW

LPLQGUHXGVWU NQLQJYDUWLOI OGHWIRUXGE\W WHUQH 'H WR Q\H IRUPXOHULQJHU PHG EL[DIHQ YLVWHJHQHUHOWHQRYHUOHJHQKHGPHGKHQV\QWLO HIIHNWHURJPHUXGE\WWHU5HVXOWDWHUIUDIRUV¡JL XQGHUE\JJHUDW%$<)JLYHUK¡MHHI IHNWHURJPHUXGE\WWHUVDPPHQOLJQHWPHGDQ GUHIXQJLFLGHUVHWDEHO

7DEHO%HN PSHOVHDIE\JUXVWPHOGXJRJE\JEODGSOHWLYLQWHUE\JIRUV¡J 'HUHUVSU¡MWHWJDQJHLIRUV¡JHQH

%HKDQGOLQJSnY NVWVWDGLH E\JUXVW YV

E\JUXVW YV

E\JEODGSOHW YV

PHOGXJ YV

8GE\WWHRJPHU XGE\WWHKNJKD

YV OKD

8EHKDQGOHW

3UROLQH [

3UROLQH [

3UROLQH [

%$<) [

%$<) [

%$<) [

%$<) [

%$<) [

%$<) [

%$<) [

%$<) [

$QWDOIRUV¡J

/6'

(31)

9nUE\J7RIRUV¡JXGI¡UWLYnUE\JKDYGHNXQ EHJU QVHGH DQJUHE DI V\JGRPPH PHQ ODYH DQJUHEDI E\JUXVW RJ PHOGXJ IRUHNRPL IRU V¡JHQHWDEHO¿JXU'HVXGHQYDUGHUHQ GHOI\VLRORJLVNHSOHWWHUVRPYDUVY UHDWND WHJRULVHUH 6RP XGJDQJVSXQNW HU GLVVH GDWD LNNHPHGWDJHW$OOHWHVWHGHSURGXNWHUYLVWH JRGHHIIHNWHURJVLJQL¿NDQWHPHUXGE\WWHUIRU EHN PSHOVH,EHN PSHOVHVHIIHNWHUQHYDUGHU W\GHOLJHXGVODJIRUGRVLVPHQVGHWLPLQGUH

7DEHO%HN PSHOVHDIE\JUXVWRJPHOGXJLYnUE\JIRUV¡J'HU HUVSU¡MWHWJDQJLIRUV¡JHQH

%HKDQGOLQJSnY NVWVWDGLH E\JUXVW

YV PHOGXJ

YV 8GE\WWHRJ

PHUXGE\WWH KNJKD

YV OKD

8EHKDQGOHW

3UROLQH

3UROLQH

3UROLQH

%$<)

%$<)

%$<)

%$<)

%$<)

%$<)

%$<)

%$<)

$QWDOIRUV¡J

/6'

XGVWU NQLQJYDUWLOI OGHWIRUXGE\WWHUQH'HWR Q\HIRUPXOHULQJHUPHGEL[DIHQYLVWHJHQHUHOW HQVYDJRYHUOHJHQKHGPHGKHQV\QWLOHIIHNWHU RJPHUXGE\WWHU5HVXOWDWHUIUDIRUV¡JL XQGHUE\JJHUDW%$<)JLYHUK¡MHHIIHNWHU RJPHUXGE\WWHUVDPPHQOLJQHWPHGDQGUHIXQ JLFLGHUVHWDEHO0LGOHWHUGRJLNNHVSH FLHOWVW UNWWLOEHN PSHOVHDIPHJHWNUDIWLJH DQJUHEDIPHOGXJ

(32)

)LJXU%HN PSHOVHDIE\JUXVWLYLQWHUE\JIRUV¡JRJPHUXGE\WWHIRUVSU¡MWQLQJLYLQWHUE\J RJYnUE\JIRUV¡JRJIRUV¡J

EHN PSHOVH

%HN PSHOVHDIE\JUXVW

3UROLQH %$< %$<

EHN PSHOVH

%HN PSHOVHDIE\JUXVW

3UROLQH %$< %$<

+NJKD

0HUXGE\WWHLYLQWHUE\J

+NJKD

0HUXGE\WWHLYnUE\J

3UROLQH %$< %$<

+NJKD

0HUXGE\WWHLYnUE\J

(33)

%$<) %$<)

7R\GHUOLJHUHIRUPXOHULQJHUIUD%D\HUEOHYDI SU¡YHWL'HQHQHYDUHQQ\NRPELQDWLRQ PHG EL[DIHQ RJ SURWKLRFRQD]RO KYRU GHU HU WLOI¡UWOLGWPHUHSURWKLRFRQD]ROVDPPHQOLJQHW PHG%$<)PHQVGHQDQGHQYDUHQQ\YD ULDWLRQDI3URVDURKYRUGHUHUWLOI¡UWPHUHWHEX FRQD]RORJPLQGUHSURWKLRFRQD]RO

%$<)JEL[DIHQJSURWLRFR QD]ROVWDQGDUGGRVH

%$<)JSURWKLRFRQD]ROJWHEX FRQD]ROQRUPDOGRVHJO

5HVXOWDWHUQHLQGJnUVRPHQGHODIGRNXPHQWD WLRQHQLIRUELQGHOVHPHGJRGNHQGHOVHQ5HVXO WDWHWDInUHWVDISU¡YQLQJKDUYLVWJRGHHIIHNWHU SnGHYLJWLJVWHV\JGRPPHLEnGHKYHGHRJE\J 9LQWHUKYHGH5HVXOWDWHUQHLKYHGHYLVWHULJWLJ JRGEHN PSHOVHDIVHSWRULDOLJHVRPGHUYDU HQ W\GHOLJ IRUO QJHOVH DI DIJU¡GHQV JU¡QKHG RJVLJQL¿NDQWHPHUXGE\WWHUWDEHO¿JXU ,V U%$<)YDURYHUOHJHQLHIIHNWHUYXU GHUHWLIRUKROGWLO3UROLQH

7DEHO%HN PSHOVHDIV\JGRPPHVDPWPHUXGE\WWHULKYHGHIRUV¡J)RUV¡

JHQHHUVSU¡MWHWJDQJH

%HKDQGOLQJSnY NVWVWDGLH VHSWRULD

YV VHSWRULD

YV EODG

PHOGXJ

YV .Q NNHIRG V\JH ,QGHNV

YV

JU¡QWDUHDO IDQHEODG YV

8GE\WWHRJ PHUXGE\WWH KNJKD

YV OKD

8EHKDQGOHW

3UROLQH [

3UROLQH [

3UROLQH [

%$<) [

%$<) [

%$<) [

%$<) [

%$<) [

%$<) [

3URVDUR [

$QWDOIRUV¡J

/6' QV

$QJUHEDIVHSWRULDLIRUV¡JHQHYDUIRUKROGVYLV PRGHUDWHL

(34)

)LJXU%HN PSHOVHDIVHSWRULDLKYHGHIRUV¡JPHGIRUVNHOOLJHIXQJLFLGHUKYRUDIGHHUDI SU¡YHWLGRVHULQJHU'HUHUVSU¡MWHWJDQJHLIRUV¡JHQH

+NJKD

0HUXGE\WWHLKYHGH

3UROLQH(& %$<) %$<) 3URVDUR

+NJKD

0HUXGE\WWHLKYHGH

%HN PSHOVHDIVHSWRULD

DQJUHE

%HN PSHOVHDIVHSWRULD

DQJUHE

%HN PSHOVHDIVHSWRULD

3UROLQH(& %$<) %$<) 3URVDUR

DQJUHE

%HN PSHOVHDIVHSWRULD

(35)

%HN PSHOVH DI VHSWRULD PHG IXOGGRVHULQJDI%$<)

%HN PSHOVHDIVHSWRULDPHG NYDUWGRVHULQJDI%$<)

8EHKDQGOHWOHGPHGDQJUHEDI VHSWRULD

Referencer

RELATEREDE DOKUMENTER

Mere et enfant, pointe séche

3n SURMHNWHWV RSVWDUWVVHPLQDU EOHY GHU ODJW HQ GHWDOMHUHW SODQ IRU SURMHNWHWV IRUO¡E )RUO¡EHW L SURMHNWHW KDU EHVWnHW DI HQ U NNH IDVHU , GHQ I¡UVWH IDVH EOHY

I overensstemmelse med Mikkelsen (l 992) kan disse principper sammenfattes i fem punkter: l) der anføres en ækvivalent, ikke en forklaring, som i en korrekt

for ventilerede, uharpede Kartofler paa Samsø.. vise sig Forskel i Overvintringssvindet, og af de danske For- søg, at det samme kan være Tilfældet med

Omkostninger, der direkte relaterer sig $l gennemførelse af den årlige audit af energi- besparelser, herunder personaleomkostninger $l gennemførelse af intern audit, hono- rering

T i l Grundfonden henregnes ikke de i tz 1 L it r.. den er taget til Zndtcrgt, at In te t er fort til U d g ift, som ikke er reglementeret eller forud bevilget,

Bygevejr over Kulsø... Solnedgang ved

Med henblik på at fastlægge effekt af fødevarematrice blev 12 raske unge mænd tildelt en proteintæt kost, der indeholdt 30 g isotopmærket protein (L-[1- 13 C]phenylala- nin), i