7UDILNPRGHOEHUHJQLQJHUIRUWXQQHOHQ 8QGHUN¡EHQKDYQVKDYQ
2WWR$QNHU1LHOVHQ)RUVNQLQJVDGMXQNW3K' 7KRPDV,VUDHOVHQ)RUVNQLQJVDVVLVWHQWFLYLQJ (ULN5XGH1LHOVHQ)RUVNQLQJVDVVLVWHQWFLYLQJ
,QVWLWXWIRU3ODQO JQLQJ,)3'DQPDUNV7HNQLVNH8QLYHUVLWHW'78
%\JQLQJ/\QJE\
7HOHIRQ)D[(PDLORQLHOVHQ#LYWEGWXGN
,QWURGXNWLRQ
'HQQHDUWLNHOEHVNULYHUKRYHGUHVXOWDWHUQHDIHQU NNHEHUHJQLQJHUDIWUDILNDOHNRQVHNYHQVHU DIHQWXQQHOXQGHUGHQ¡VWOLJHGHODI.¡EHQKDYQV+DYQ$UEHMGHWHUXGI¡UWIRU7UDQVSRUWUnGHW DI *,67 SURJUDPPHW YHG ,QVWLWXW IRU 3ODQO JQLQJ ,)3 'DQPDUNV 7HNQLVNH 8QLYHUVLWHW '78'HY VHQWOLJVWHUHVXOWDWHUIUHPJnUDI7UDQVSRUWUnGHWVUDSSRUWRPHPQHW´+DYQHWXQ QHOL.¡EHQKDYQ±YXUGHULQJHURJKRYHGVS¡UJVPnO´PHQVPRGHOOHUQHVIRUXGV WQLQJHU RJUHVXOWDWHUYLOEOLYHJHQQHPJnHWL,)3¶VUDSSRUW´7UDILNDQDO\VHUDI +DYQHWXQQHOSURMHNWHW´
RJ´+DYQHWXQQHOSURMHNWHW±'HWDOMHUHGHUHVXOWDWHU´EHJU QVHWRSODJ
3U VHQWDWLRQDISURMHNWHW
$UEHMGHWNDQVHVLIRUO QJHOVHDIWRWLGOLJHUHXGUHGQLQJHURP+DYQHWXQQHOHQ7UDILNPLQLVWHUL HWRJ9HMGLUHNWRUDWHW.ODUHNRQNOXVLRQHUIUDGLVVHUDSSRUWHUHUVnOHGHVWDJHWWLO HIWHUUHWQLQJ XGHQ \GHUOLJHUH EHUHJQLQJHU 'HWWH J OGHU HNVHPSHOYLV 7UDILNPLQLVWHULHWV NRQ NOXVLRQGHUDGYDUHGHPRGEUXJHUEHWDOLQJVRPILQDQVLHULQJDIWXQQHOHQ
,GpHQPHGDUEHMGHWYDUDWJLYHHQRYHURUGQHWYXUGHULQJDIDOWHUQDWLYHXGI¡UHOVHUDIDQO JJHW XQGHUIRUVNHOOLJHSODQIRUXGV WQLQJHU'HWWHVNXOOHIRUHJnPHGKHQEOLNSnDWNXQQHJLYHDQEH IDOLQJHUWLOGHQQXYHGWDJQHPHUHGHWDOMHUHGHXGUHGQLQJ)RUPnOHWKDUVnOHGHVLNNHY UHWDW JLYHHQXGW¡PPHQGHXGUHGQLQJRP+DYQHWXQQHOSURMHNWHW
%HUHJQLQJVIRUXGV WQLQJHURJPHWRGHU
3URMHNWHWKDYGHHQIRUKROGVYLVNRUWWLGVIULVWKYRUIRUGHUEOHYWDJHWXGJDQJVSXQNWLHQHNVLVWH UHQGH WUDILNPRGHO UHVWDGVWUDILNPRGHOOHQ ± 270 EHVNUHYHW L &DUO %UR *UXSSHQ 270NXQQHIRUKROGVYLVOHWLQWHJUHUHVRJNRRUGLQHUHVPHG,)3VPRGHOY UNW¡MHUGDWDRJPR GHOOHUVnYHO('%VRPGDWDP VVLJWKYLONHWQDWXUOLJYLVYDUHQIRUGHO6DPWLGLJHUPRGHOOHQ IDJOLJWVHWYHOHJQHWWLODWXGI¡UHIRUKROGVYLVGHWDOMHUHGHDQDO\VHUDIWUDILNNHQRYHU+DYQHVQLW WHW
270HULDUEHMGHWEHQ\WWHWWLODWPRGHOOHUHWXUSURGXNWLRQWXUIRUGHOLQJ WUDQVSRUWPLGGHOYDOJ RJUXWHYDOJ5XWHYDOJHWL270HUNDSDFLWHWVDIK QJLJWLP\OGUHWLGHQIRUVDPWOLJHVWU NQLQJHU RJIHHGEDFNVLNUHUDWHYHQWXHOOHNDSDFLWHWVSUREOHPHURJVnSnYLUNHUWXUIRUGHOLQJRJWUDQVSRUW PLGGHOYDOJ,)3VUXWHYDOJVPRGHOHUHIWHUI¡OJHQGHEHQ\WWHWWLOHQPHUHGHWDOMHUHWEHVNULYHOVHDI UXWHYDOJ'HQQHEHVNULYHOVHHUNDSDFLWHWVDIK QJLJWDJHUKHQV\QWLOIRUVNHOOLJHWLOI OGLJHYDUL DWLRQHUDIWUDILNDQWHUVUXWHYDOJVDPWWLOIRUVNHOOHLWUDILNDQWHUVSU IHUHQFHU1LHOVHQ 6nOHGHVHU GHQ EHQ\WWHGH IUHPJDQJVPnGH HQ V\PELRVH PHOOHP ,)3V UXWHYDOJVPRGHO RJ 270
(QGHODIDUEHMGHWEHVWRGLDWHWDEOHUHYHMQHWWHWIUD270LHW*HRJUDILVN,QIRUPDWLRQVV\VWHP
*,6RJHIWHUI¡OJHQGHNRRUGLQHUHGHWPHGHW*,6EDVHUHWYHMQHWGHUWLGOLJHUH HUGDQQHWSn ,)3'HWWHJDYHQ\GHUOLJHUHNYDOLWHWVNRQWURODIGDWDJUXQGODJHWLIRUKROGWLOGHQNYDOLWHWVNRQ WUROGHUWLGOLJHUHHUIRUHWDJHWDIGHWRGDWDV W
7LOEUXJIRUWRONQLQJHQDIUHVXOWDWHUQHEOHYHWVSHFLDOXGYLNOHW*,6Y UNW¡MDQYHQGWWLOIUHP VWLOOLQJ DI VWDQGDUGLOOXVWUDWLRQHU VRP IHNV RYHUVLJWVNRUW GHWDLONRUW RJ GLIIHUHQVNRUW 'HWWH Y UNW¡MJMRUGHGHWPXOLJWDWDQDO\VHUHUHVXOWDWHUQHIUDGHPDQJHN¡UVOHUSnHQHIIHNWLYPnGH /LJHOHGHVEOHYGHUXGYLNOHWHQPHWRGHWLODWKROGHVW\USnGHPDQJHDOWHUQDWLYHURJVFHQDULHU 1LHOVHQHWDO
,GHWI¡OJHQGHRPWDOHVI¡UVWKYLONHEHUHJQLQJHUGHUHUIRUHWDJHWLSURMHNWHW+HUHIWHUEHVNULYHV UHVXOWDWHUQHSnHWRYHURUGQHWQLYHDXRJGHUVOXWWHVDIPHGHQDQEHIDOLQJWLO\GHUOLJHUHXQGHU V¡JHOVHURJHQNRQNOXVLRQ
)RUHWDJQHEHUHJQLQJHU
)RUDW EHO\VH IRUVNHOOLJHYDULDQWHUDI +DYQHWXQQHOHQHUGHU IRUHWDJHW EHUHJQLQJHU IRU IRU VNHOOLJH DOWHUQDWLYH XGIRUPQLQJHU DI WUDILNQHWWHW 'LVVH DOWHUQDWLYHU HU IDVWODJW VnOHGHV DW GH DOOHUHSU VHQWHUHUSULQFLSLHOWIRUVNHOOLJHO¡VQLQJHU)RUPnOHWKHUPHGHUDWXQGHUV¡JHRPGHU HUQRJOHNDWHJRULHUDIO¡VQLQJHUGHUNDQIRUNDVWHVHOOHUDQEHIDOHVLQGHQHQJUXQGLJHUHXGUHG QLQJ'HXQGHUV¡JWHO¡VQLQJHUHU
• ,QJHQ+DYQHWXQQHOEDVLVVFHQDULHU
• /RNDOWXQQHOIUD*LWWHUYHMWLO$PDJHU6WUDQGYHM PHGHOOHUVSRU
• 5HJLRQDOWXQQHOIUD/\QJE\YHMWLO$PDJHU6WUDQGYHMVSRU PHGWUDILNVDQHUHWX QGUHWHOOHUVSRUHW$PDJHU6WUDQGYHM
• VWOLJ2PIDUWVYHMIUD/\QJE\YHMRJKHOHYHMHQWLO$PDJHUPRWRUYHMHQ HQWHQODQJV/RVVHSODGVYHMHOOHUYLDHQVSRUHWUHVWDGV%RXOHYDUG
$OOH +DYQHWXQQHODOWHUQDWLYHU LQNOXGHUHU WR EXVUXWHU JHQQHP WXQQHOHQ HQ IRUO QJHOVH DI OL QLH IUD +ROPHQ WLO VWHUSRUW VWDWLRQ VDPW HQ Q\ 6EXV IUD
VWHUSRUW WLO 6XQGE\YHVWHU 3ODGV $OWHUQDWLYHUQH VHV Sn )LJXU
(IWHU GH LQGOHGHQGH EHUHJQLQ JHUEOHYGHWEHVOXWWHWDWIRUHWD JH EHUHJQLQJHU KYRU WR DI DO WHUQDWLYHUQH UHJLRQDO WXQQHO PHGVSRUHW$PDJHU6WUDQGYHM RJ UHJLRQDO WXQQHO PHG ¡VWOLJ RPIDUWVYHM DG /RVVHSODGVYHM EOHYNRPELQHUHWPHGHQWUDILN VDQHULQJDIE\PLGWHQ
'HUHUIRUHWDJHWLQGOHGHQGHUX WHYDOJVEHUHJQLQJHU IRU YHMQHWWHWGDHYHQWXHOOHSURJQR VHXVLNNHUKHGHUKHULNNHIRUVW\U
UHUUHVXOWDWHUQHEHUHJQLQJHUIRUnUPHGGHWIXOGHPRGHONRPSOHNVRJIRUYLVVHDOWHUQDWL YHULnU;;VYDUHQGHWLOSURJQRVHnUHWPHGIXOGWXGE\JJHWUHVWDG6FHQDULHUIRU E\XGYLNOLQJPYI¡OJHUIRUXGV WQLQJHUQHLUHVWDGVWUDILNPRGHOOHQGHUL¡YULJWSnGHWWHSXQNW E\JJHUSnVWRUWVHWVDPPHIRUXGV WQLQJHUVRP+RYHGVWDGVWUDILNPRGHOOHQ
(QGYLGHUHHUGHUUHJQHWSnHWVFHQDULRPHGHW¡JHWDQWDOEROLJHURJDUEHMGVSODGVHUSn+ROPHQ Sn5HIVKDOH¡HQRJL6XQGE\1RUGLnU;;VRPYXUGHUHVDWVYDUHWLOHQIXOGXGQ\WWHOVHDI DUHDOUXPPHOLJKHGHQ)RUXGV WQLQJHUQHKHUIRUHUGHILQHUHWDI7UDQVSRUWUnGHW
'HUHUPHG,)3VUXWHYDOJVPRGHORJVnIRUHWDJHWHQVNLWVHP VVLJEHUHJQLQJDIODVWELOWUDILNWLO .¡EHQKDYQV1RUGKDYQ%HUHJQLQJHQNDQJLYH HQYLVLGpRP+DYQHWXQQHOHQVEHW\GQLQJIRU ODVWELOWUDILN7XUP¡QVWUHWE\JJHUSnHQWLGOLJHUHXQGHUV¡JHOVHIRUHWDJHWIRU.¡EHQKDYQV+DYQ DI.¡EHQKDYQV+DQGHOVK¡MVNROHDVVLVWHUHWDI,)31LHOVHQ
'HUXGRYHUEOHYGHUIRUHWDJHWHQYXUGHULQJDIJHQHUHUHWWUDILNVRPI¡OJHDIWXQQHOHQ6W¡UUHO VHVRUGHQHQKHUDIYDUGRJVnOLOOHRJPHGVnVWRUXVLNNHUKHGLIRUKROGWLO¡YULJHHIIHNWHUDWGHQ LNNHNRPPHQWHUHVLGHWI¡OJHQGH
)LJXU(QSULQFLSVNLWVHDIEHUHJQLQJDOWHUQDWLYHUQH
(QGHOLJEOHYGHUIRUHWDJHWHQWHNQLVNYXUGHULQJDIGHWLOJUXQGOLJJHQGHWXUP¡QVWHUEHVNULYHOVHUV WXUPDWULFHUVWURY UGLJKHGPHG030(PHWRGHQGHUHUEHVNUHYHWL1LHOVHQ
'HUHUVDPOHWIRUHWDJHWFDPRGHON¡UVOHUPHGUXWHYDOJVPRGHOOHQSnEDJJUXQG DI HQ OLOOH VQHVNRPSOHWWHN¡UVOHUPHG270
(QKDYQHWXQQHOVYLUNQLQJSnWUDILNP¡QVWUHW
'HI¡OJHQGHDIVQLWEHVNULYHUNRUWGHY VHQWOLJVWHUHVXOWDWHUDIPRGHON¡UVOHUQHRJGHNRQNOXVL RQHUGHUNDQGUDJHV
7811(/(16)81.7,21
7UDILNNHQ L HQ +DYQHWXQQHO YHQWHV DW EOLYH IRUKROGVYLV ORNDO 6H )LJXU
&LUNDKDOYGHOHQDIWUDILNNHQ L+DYQH WXQQHOHQ IUD 6M OODQGVVLGHQ VWDPPHU IUDHQIRUKROGVYLVVPDONRUULGRU¡VWIRU /\QJE\PRWRUYHMHQSULP UWIUDVWHU EUR *HQWRIWH RJ /\QJE\ 3n $PD JHUVLGHQHUGHSULP UHPnODWILQGHSn GHWQRUG¡VWOLJH$PDJHU.XQPHJHWIn WXUH IRUWV WWHU YLGHUH DG IRUELQGHOVHQ WLO .DOYHERGEURHQ 'HWWH J OGHU DOOH DOWHUQDWLYHUVHOYIRUSURMHNWHWPHGHQ
VWOLJ5LQJYHM/RVVHSODGVYHM+HOOHU LNNH UHVXQGVIRUELQGHOVHQ HOOHU OXIW KDYQHQ HU GH VWRUH GHVWLQDWLRQHU IRU WUDILNNHQ L WXQQHOHQ (Q +DYQHWXQQHO YLOVnOHGHVSULP UWSnYLUNHWUDILNP¡Q VWUHWSnVWHUEURLGHQLQGUHE\VDPW Sn GHQ QRUGOLJH GHO DI $PDJHU (W NRQNUHW HNVHPSHO Sn KDYQHWXQQHOHQV SULP UWORNDOHIXQNWLRQHUDWGHUNXQ RYHUIO\WWHV HQ OLOOH P QJGH WUDILN IUD PRWRUULQJYHMHQFDWXUH
$)/$671,1*$)%<0,'7(1
'HQY VHQWOLJVWHNRQNOXVLRQGHUNDQGUDJHVSnEDJJUXQGDIEHUHJQLQJHUQHHUDW+DYQHWXQ QHOHQJLYHUHQP UNEDUDIODVWQLQJDIGHQLQGUHE\7UDILNNHQSn.QLSSHOVEURYLOSnODQJWVLJW EOLYHQ VWHQKDOYHUHWLGHWGHWPHVWHDIGHQJHQQHPN¡UHQGHWUDILNRYHU.QLSSHOVEURYLOKDYH IRUGHODIDWEHQ\WWH+DYQHWXQQHOHQRJVnVHOYRPGHQLQGUHE\LNNHWUDILNVDQHUHV'HW¡YULJH )LJXU7UDILNNHQJHQQHPKDYQHWXQQHOHQ.XQGHWEXQGW DIWXUHGHUSDVVHUHUWXQQHOHQYLVHV7DOOHQHDQJLYHU ELOHUSnGHHQNHOWHVWU NQLQJHU
YHMQHWLGHQLQGUHE\DIODVWHV PHG3n)LJXUVHV DIODVWQLQJHQ DI GHQ LQGUH E\
'HW EHP UNHV LJHQ DW RYHQ Q YQWHDIODVWQLQJHUVNHUXGHQ DWGHULPRGHOOHQHU QGUHWSn GH WUDILNDOH IRUXGV WQLQJHU L E\PLGWHQ
%<8'9,./,1*(16 ())(.7 3c(1+$91(7811(/
(IIHNWHQ DI KDYQHWXQQHOHQ YDULHUHU LNNH PDUNDQW L EH UHJQLQJVDOWHUQDWLYHUQH ;; RJ ;; VXS SOHUHW PHGIXOG XGQ\WWHOVH DI E\XGYLNOLQJV PXOLJKHGHUQH
Sn5HIVKDOH¡HQPYGHUHUGRJHQWHQGHQVWLOHQVW¡UUHDIODVWQLQJDIGHQLQGUHE\LVLWXDWLRQHU QHKYRUUHVWDGHQRJDUHDOHUQHSn5HIVKDOH¡HQPYHUXGE\JJHW'HWJHQHUHOWVW¡UUHSUHVSn YHMQHWWHW L VLWXDWLRQHUQH PHG PDNVLPDO E\XGYLNOLQJ EHW\GHU VnOHGHV DW GHU RSQnV HQ VW¡UUH IRUGHOYHGHWDEOHULQJDIHQ+DYQHWXQQHO
75$),.,7811(/(1
(WDEOHULQJDI HQ+DYQHWXQQHOYLOLI¡OJHEHUHJQLQJHUQHDOOHUHGHLGDJHQVVLWXDWLRQIO\WWHVn PHJHWWUDILNIUDGHQLQGUHE\WLO+DYQHWXQQHOHQDWGHWLNNHYLOY UHWLOVWU NNHOLJWDWHWDEOHUH HQWRVSRUHWWXQQHO6HOYLHQIUHPWLGLJVLWXDWLRQKYRUEnGHUHVWDGHQ5HIVKDOH¡HQRJ6XQGE\
1RUGHUXGE\JJHWW\GHUPRGHON¡UVOHUQHSnDWHQILUHVSRUHWIRUELQGHOVHYLONXQQHNODUHWUDILN EHODVWQLQJHQPHQGRJPHGHWODYWVHUYLFHQLYHDXLGHWPDNVLPDOHXGE\JQLQJVVFHQDULRPHG EnGHUHVWDGHQ+ROPHQ5HIVKDOH¡HQRJ6XQGE\1RUGIXOGWXGE\JJHW0RGHON¡UVOHUQHYL VHUDWGHUNDQIRUYHQWHVNQDSN¡UHW¡MHUL+DYQHWXQQHOHQLnURJN¡UH W¡MHULPDNVLPDOVFHQDULHWIRUnU;;
)LJXU 7UDILNP QJGHGLIIHUHQVHU L IRUKROG WLO XGJDQJVQHWWHW IRU VDPPHnU
795)25%,1'(/6(
(Q+DYQHWXQQHOPHGUHJLRQDOIRUELQGHOVHYLD
*LWWHUYHM 6WUDQGY QJHW 5\YDQJV $OOp RYHU NDVHUQHDUHDOHUQH WLO /\QJE\YHM YLO EOLYH DQ YHQGW DI IOHUH ELOLVWHU HQG HQ +DYQHWXQQHO XGHQ GHQQH WY UIRUELQGHOVH 7UDILNDOW KDU WY UIRUELQGHOVHQ VWRU VDPPHQK QJ PHG +DYQHWXQQHOHQ LGHW HQ VWRU GHO DI ELOLVWHUQH YLOEHQ\WWHEHJJH6H)LJXU +YLVWY UIRU ELQGHOVHQ LNNH HWDEOHUHV YLO GHU VNH HQ PHU EHODVWQLQJ DI 6WUDQGERXOHYDUGHQ -DJWYHM RJ 6WUDQGYHM7XERUJYHM 6H )LJXU (WDEOHUHV IRUELQGHOVHQ YLO GHU VNH HQ EHW\GHOLJ DIODVW QLQJ DI RYHQQ YQWH YHMH VDPW DI /\QJE\
YHM1¡UUH$OOp6H)LJXU'HWDQEHIDOHVGHU IRUDWVDPPHQN GH GH WRSURMHNWHU 'HWXQ GHUVWUHJHV DW HQ +DYQHWXQQHO XGHQ WY UIRU ELQGHOVHQ YLO PHGI¡UH HQ ¡JHW WUDILNEHODVW QLQJLVWRUHGHOHDIVWHUEURVEROLJRPUnGHU
)LJXU 7UDILNGLIIHUHQVHU PHOOHP XGJDQJVVL WXDWLRQHQ XGHQ KDYQHWXQQHO RJ VLWXDWLRQHQ PHGKDYQHWXQQHORJWY UIRUELQGHOVH
)LJXU 7UDILNGLIIHUHQVHU PHOOHP VLWXDWLRQHUQH PHG RJ XGHQ KDYQHWXQQHOHQ , EHJJH WLOI OGH XGHQWY UIRUELQGHOVH
)LJXU+HUVHVKYRUGDQWUDILNNHQIUDKDYQHWXQ QHOHQIRUGHOHUVLJLGHWQRUGOLJH.¡EHQKDYQ
7UDQVSRUWPLGGHOYDOJ
0RGHON¡UVOHUQHYLVHUDWIRUELQGHOVHQNXQYLOKDYHEHJU QVHWLQGIO\GHOVHSnYDOJHWDIWUDQV SRUWPLGGHOLRPUnGHUXGHQIRU5HIVKDOH¡HQ+ROPHQRJ6XQGE\1RUG6nOHGHVYLOIRUELQGHO VHQLNNHVRPPDQHOOHUVNXQQHIU\JWHRYHUIO\WWHWUDILNIUDUHVWDGVEDQHQEHJJHJUHQHWLO ELOWUDILNJHQQHPWXQQHOHQOLJHVRPGHQUHODWLYWK¡MHDQGHODINROOHNWLYWUDILNWLOUHVWDGHQNXQ UHGXFHUHVPDUJLQDOW0HGKHQV\QWLO5HIVKDOH¡HQ+ROPHQRJ6XQGE\1RUGJLYHUIRUELQGHO VHQYLDGHIRUXGVDWWHEXVOLQLHUJHQQHPWXQQHOHQHQVnVWRUIRUEHGULQJLGHQNROOHNWLYHWUDILN EHWMHQLQJDWEUXJHQDINROOHNWLYWUDILNWLOGLVVH]RQHU¡JHVKHUYHGIRUVN\GHVGHQVDPOHGHIRU GHOLQJDIWXUHLPRGHOOHQWLOIRUGHOIRUNROOHNWLYWUDQVSRUWHWXYHQWHWUHVXOWDWDIPRGHON¡UVOHU QH
7UDILNVDQHULQJDIGHQLQGUHE\
.¡EHQKDYQV.RPPXQHVDIGHOLQJKDULVNLWVHUHWQRJOHSULQFLSSHUIRUWUDILNVDQHULQJDI GHQLQGUHE\VDPW&KULVWLDQVKDYQ.¡EHQKDYQV.RPPXQH .RQVHNYHQVHUIRU ELOWUD ILNNHQHUEOHYHWYXUGHUHWSnEDJJUXQGDIGLVVHUHVWULNWLRQHU'HWWHHUJMRUWYHGDWXGO JJHELO WUDILNNHQ IUD HQ 2'PDWUL[ IUD HQ WLOVYDUHQGH 270N¡UVHO XGHQ WUDILNVDQHULQJ Sn HW YHMQHW PHGWUDILNVDQHULQJ
'HWHUVRPLNRPPXQHQVIRUVODJVRPHU LOOXVWUHUHWSn)LJXUIRUXGVDWDWGHQLQ GUHE\HURSGHOWLILUH]RQHURJDWGHWHU PHJHW YDQVNHOLJW IRU HQ ELOLVW DW SDVVHUH IUD pQ ]RQH WLO HQ DQGHQ 'HUXGRYHU HU
&KULVWLDQVKDYQ L EHUHJQLQJHQ RSGHOW L WR ]RQHUKYRUGHQQRUGOLJVWHKDUDGJDQJIUD 5HIVKDOH¡HQRJKDYQHWXQQHOIRUELQGHOVHQ 'HU HU LNNH WDOH RP DW GHQ LQGUH E\ HU KHOWOXNNHWIRUJHQQHPN¡UVHOPHQGHWHU JMRUWPHJHWEHVY UOLJW+YRUGHWLNNHKDU Y UHWPXOLJWDWILQGHNRQNUHWHIRUDQVWDOW QLQJHU GHU NXQQH VLNUH GHQ ¡QVNHGH UH GXNWLRQ DI ELON¡UVOHQ HU GHW UHQW PRGHO WHNQLVN IRUXGVDW DW NDSDFLWHWHQ RJ KD VWLJKHGHQ HUUHGXFHUHW'HUXGRYHU HUKD VWLJKHGHUQHRJNDSDFLWHWHUQHJHQHUHOWV QNHW
'LVVHUHVWULNWLRQHUIRUELOWUDILNNHQYLVHUHQYLVHIIHNWSnWUDILNNHQL+DYQHWXQQHOHQGHUYLOVWL JHPHGFDVRPI¡OJHDIWUDILNVDQHULQJHQ(WDEOHULQJHQDIWXQQHOHQXGHQWUDILNVDQH ULQJIO\WWHUNQDSKDOYGHOHQDIWUDILNNHQIUD.QLSSHOVEURWLO+DYQHWXQQHOHQ*HQQHPI¡UHOVHDI UHODWLYWVW UNHUHVWULNWLRQHUIRUELOWUDILNNHQLGHQLQGUHE\YLOEHW\GHDWDIODVWQLQJHQDI.QLS )LJXU .¡EHQKDYQV NRPPXQHV IRUVODJ WLO KYRUGDQ GHQLQGUHE\WUDILNVDQHUHV
SHOVEUR¡JHVWLOFDDIWUDILNNHQLnU8GRYHUDIODVWQLQJHQSn.QLSSHOVEURYLOGHQ UHODWLYHDIODVWQLQJDIJDGHUQHL'HQLQGUHE\Y UHEHJU QVHWLVW¡UUHOVHVRUGHQHQ'HW HUDQWDJHOLJYLVXGWU\NIRUDWGHELOLVWHUGHUY OJHUDWN¡UHDG+DYQHWXQQHOHQHOOHU/DQJHEUR HIWHUHQWUDILNVDQHULQJYLONRPPHIUDPDQJHIRUVNHOOLJHUXWHU
,GHNRPPHQGHXQGHUV¡JHOVHUQHE¡UGHUDUEHMGHVYLGHUHPHGDWYXUGHUHHIIHNWHUQHDIUHVWULN WLRQHUIRUELOWUDILNNHQ'HWDQEHIDOHVPLQGVWDWLQGGUDJHRPUnGHWLQGHQIRU6¡HUQHLGHWGHEH UHJQHGHWUDILNP QJGHUVYLQJHUPHJHWSnSDUDOOHOOHYHMHLKHOHGHWWHRPUnGH
/LQLHI¡ULQJHUSn$PDJHU
3nEDVLVDI GH PDQJHRYHURUGQHGH DOWHUQDWLYHU VH DIVQLW HU GHURSQnHW HQ UHODWLY VROLG EXQGIRUDWULGVHIRUGHOHRJXOHPSHUYHGGHIRUVNHOOLJHPXOLJHO¡VQLQJHUSn$PDJHURS'HWWH J¡UHVLUHVWHQDIDIVQLW
7UDILNP QJGHUQHSn$PDJHUYDULHUHUJHQHUHOWJDQVNHEHWUDJWHOLJWDIK QJLJWDIGHXQGHUV¡JWH OLQLHI¡ULQJHU RJ GHUHV XGIRUPQLQJ Sn $PDJHU 'HWWH VHV DI IRUVNHOOHQH PHOOHP )LJXU RJ )LJXU(NVHPSHOYLVJLYHUGHWHQPDUNDQWIRUVNHOSnWUDILNNHQVIRUGHOLQJRP$PDJHU6WUDQG YHM KDVWLJKHGVG PSHV IRUEOLYHU X QGUHW HOOHU XGYLGHV WLO HQ VSRUHW YHM PHG PLGWHUUDEDW 'HWNDQIRUYHQWHVDWVHOYGLPHQVLRQHULQJDIYLJWLJHYHMNU\GVYLONXQQHSnYLUNHGHQRYHURUG QHGHIRUGHOLQJDIELOWUDILNNHQ'HWHUGHUIRUYLJWLJWDWIRUHWDJHPRGHON¡UVOHUIRUHQU NNHOL QLHI¡ULQJHURJO¡VQLQJVPRGHOOHULGHNRPPHQGHIRUXQGHUV¡JHOVHU,GHQIRUELQGHOVHEHP U NHVDWRSWLPHULQJDIGHHQNHOWHKRYHGDOWHUQDWLYHUPnVNHNDQKDYHEHW\GQLQJIRUGHQRYHU RUGQHGHEHVOXWQLQJ,V UIRU/RVVHSODGVYHMDOWHUQDWLYHWNDQWUDILNP QJGHUQHIRUYHQWHVDWYD ULHUHHQGHODOWHIWHUKYLONHWVHUYLFHQLYHDXRJKYLONHQGHWDLOXGIRUPQLQJGHUY OJHV
)LJXU'LIIHUHQVHUPHOOHPHQUHJLRQDOKDYQH WXQQHOPHG¡VWOLJRPIDUWVYHMRJXGJDQJVDOWHUQD WLYHW
)LJXU 'LIIHUHQVHU PHOOHP HQ ORNDO KDYQHWXQ QHOPHGVSRURJXGJDQJVDOWHUQDWLYHW
$0$*(5675$1'9(-
6W¡UVWHGHOHQDIGHQWUDILNGHULGDJHQVWUDILNVLWXDWLRQNXQQHKDYHIRUGHODIDWDQYHQGH+DYQH WXQQHOHQKDUHW ULQGHSnGHW¡VWOLJH$PDJHU'HWHUGHUIRUUHQWWUDILNDOWY VHQWOLJWPHGHQ JRG DGJDQJ WLO GHW ¡VWOLJH $PDJHU $PDJHU 6WUDQGYHM HU HQ QDWXUOLJ IRUELQGHOVH WLO DW OHGH GHQQHWUDILN
7UDILNEHUHJQLQJHUQH YLVHU DW KYLV IUHPNRPPHOLJKHGHQ DG
$PDJHU6WUDQGYHMUHGXFHUHV YHG HQ WUDILNVDQHULQJYLO WUD ILNNHQEORWOHGHVDGORNDOYHMHQHSnVWDPDJHUVH)LJXU )RU YLVVH ORNDOYHMH NDQ GHW EHW\GH RS WLO HQ IRUGREOLQJ DI WUDILNVWU¡PPHQH+YLV$PDJHU6WUDQGYHMIRUEOLYHUX QGUHW YLOGHUDOOHUHGHPHGGHQDNWXHOOHWUDILNVLWXDWLRQY UHNDSD FLWHWVSUREOHPHU Sn GHQ QRUGOLJH GHO DI YHMHQ VH )LJXU +YLV GHQ XGE\JJHV WLO HQ ILUHVSRUHW YHM YLO WUDILNNHQ KHU VWLJHPDUNDQWPHQVDPWLGLJYLOWUDILNP QJGHUQHUHGXFHUHV SnGHSDUDOOHOOHYHMHSnVWDPDJHUVH)LJXU
/266(3/$'69(-
(WDEOHULQJ DI HQ K¡MNODVVHW YHM L /RVVHSODGVYHMVOLQLHQ YLO IO\WWHVnVWRUHWUDILNP QJGHUWLOGHQQHYHMDWGHQE¡UY UH VSRUHW'HW HUGRJ EHJU QVHWKYRU VWRU HQ GHO DI WUDILN NHQGHUNRPPHU IUD+DYQHWXQQHOHQXQGHUDI WUDILN NHQ IUD +DYQHWXQQHOHQ YLO IRUWV WWH DG /RVVHSODGVYHM Sn WURGVDIDWWUDILNNHQDG/RVVHSODGVYHMHUOLJHVnVWRUVRPSn +DYQHWXQQHOHQ 6H )LJXU 'HUIRU HU GHU KHOOHU LNNH Vn
)LJXU(IIHNWHQDIHQX QGUHW
$PDJHU6WUDQGYHM )LJXU(IIHNWHQDIHQWUDILN
VDQHUHW$PDJHU6WUDQGYHM )LJXU(IIHNWHQDIHQVSRUHW
$PDJHU6WUDQGYHM
)LJXU 'HWWH UXWHEXQGW YLVHU KYRUGDQ WUDILNNHQ IUD KDYQHWXQ QHOHQ IRUGHOHU VLJ L /RVVHSODGV YHMVDOWHUQDWLYHW
VWRUWEHKRYIRUDWRPO JJH
&KULVWPDV 0¡OOHUV 3ODGV VRP PDQ PnVNH NXQQH IRUYHQWH (Q +DYQHWXQQHO RJ HQ Q\ YHM DG /RVVH SODGVYHMVOLQLHQ Pn DOWVn EHWUDJWHVVRPWRVHOYVW Q GLJH SURMHNWHU , GH PDN VLPDOH E\XGYLNOLQJVVFHQD ULHU JLYHU /RVVHSODGVYHM LPLGOHUWLG HQ S Q DIODVW QLQJDI$PDJHU6WUDQGYHM LGHW /RVVHSODGVYHM DIODVWHU SDUDOOHOYHMH Sn 9HVWDPD JHU GHU LJHQ DIODVWHU YHMH Sn0LGWDPDJHUVRPLVLG VWH HQGH DIODVWHU $PDJHU 6WUDQGYHM L IRUKROG WLO
+DYQHWXQQHODOWHUQDWLYHUGHUIRUWV WWHVDG$PDJHU6WUDQGYHM'HUHUVnOHGHVLNNHWDOHRPHQ GLUHNWHVDPPHQK QJPHOOHP+DYQHWXQQHOHQRJ/RVVHSODGVYHMPHQ/RVVHSODGVYHMNRPSHQ VHUHU DI DQGUH nUVDJHU IRU GHQ EHW\GHOLJH Y NVW L WUDILNNHQ DG $PDJHU 6WUDQGYHM VRP GHU VDPWLGLJWIRUYHQWHVDWEOLYH,IRUKROGWLOWUDILNVLWXDWLRQHQXGHQ/RVVHSODGVYHMRJ+DYQHWXQ QHOHQYLOGHUVNHHQP UNEDUDIODVWQLQJDIYHMQHWWHWSn9HVWDPDJHUIHNVRSWLOSn$PD JHU) OOHGYHM'HRYHQQ YQWHNRQVHNYHQVHUHULOOXVWUHUHWSn)LJXU
(QVWRUGHODIWUDILNNHQSnHQQ\/RVVHSODGVYHMYLOY OJHUXWHQ/DQJHEUR/RVVHSODGVYHMVRP DOWHUQDWLYWLO&HQWUXPIRUELQGHOVHQ.DOYHERG%U\JJH9DVE\JDGH6M OODQGVEURHQ'HWYLO EHW\GHHQ¡JHWWUDILNSn/DQJHEURRJGHUYHGPRGYLUNH+DYQHWXQQHOHQVDIODVWQLQJKHUDILOOX VWUHUHWSn)LJXU'HQQHHIIHNWYLODQWDJHOLJYLVNXQQHPRGYLUNHVLGHWDLOSURMHNWHULQJHQDI NU\GVHWPHOOHP$UWLOOHULYHMRJ$PDJHU%RXOHYDUG'HWDQEHIDOHVDWXGI¡UH\GHUOLJHUHPRGHO N¡UVOHUIRUDWRSWLPHUH/RVVHSODGVYHMVOLQLHQGDGHQQHKHUYHGPXOLJYLVYLOEOLYHPHUHIDYRUD EHO'HUXGRYHUYLOHQPHUHK¡MNODVVHWO¡VQLQJPXOLJYLVDIODVWHGHQLQGUHE\\GHUOLJHUHVDPW DIODVWHWUDILNNHQSnORNDOYHMHQHSn$PDJHU'HWDQEHIDOHVRJVnDWEHUHJQHWUDILNNRQVHNYHQVHU IRUHQVnGDQO¡VQLQJ
)RUODVWELOWUDILNNHQIUDKDYQHQYLOHQOLQLHI¡ULQJDG/RVVHSODGVYHMY UHDWWUDNWLYRJGHQLQGUH E\YLOEOLYHDIODVWHWPHUHIRUGHQWXQJHWUDILNHQGYHGGHDQGUHDOWHUQDWLYHU'HUHUVnOHGHVHQ NODUVDPPHQK QJPHOOHP+DYQHWXQQHOHQRJ/RVVHSODGVYHMQnUPDQDOHQHVHUSnGHQWXQJH WUDILNIUDKDYQHQ'HQWXQJHWUDILNWLORJIUD.¡EHQKDYQV+DYQXGJ¡UGRJNXQHQEHJU QVHW GHODIGHQWXQJHWUDILNLGHQLQGUHE\RJGHIRUHWDJQHEHUHJQLQJHUIRUODVWELOWUDILNHUEHW\GH OLJWPHUHXVLNUHHQGEHUHJQLQJHUQHIRUSHUVRQELOWUDILN
)LJXU (IIHNWHQ DI HQ KDYQHWXQQHO RJ HQ K¡MNODVVHIRUELQGHOVH DG /RVVHSODGVYHMLGHWPDNVLPDOHE\XGYLNOLQJVVFHQDULH
5(67$'6%28/(9$5'
(QVSRUHWUHVWDGV%RXOHYDUGYLORYHURUGQHW KDYH GH VDPPH WUDILNDOH NRQVHNYHQVHU VRP /RVVHSODGVYHMVOLQLHQ RP HQG GHU YLO VNH HQ OLGWVW¡UUHDIODVWQLQJDIYHMQHWWHWSnYHVWDPDJHU IHNVRSWLOSn$PDJHU) OOHGYHMUH VWDGV%RXOHYDUGYLOIn WUDILN DI PRWRUYHMVRP IDQJFDELOHUG¡JQLnURJGHU YLO Y UH HQ EHW\GHOLJ ODVWELOWUDILN JHQQHP
UHVWDGHQ FD DI ODVWELOWUDILNNHQ WLO 1RUGKDYQ (W VnGDQW WUDILNRPIDQJ DG UH VWDGV %RXOHYDUG HU Q SSH DFFHSWDEHOW KYLV GHQVNDOY UHHQORNDOIRUGHOLQJVYHMVRPGHW IUHPJnUDIORYHQRPUHVWDGHQ'HWEHP UNHV DW HQ VSRUHW UHVWDGV %RXOHYDUG LNNH PDU NDQW QGUHU WUDQVSRUWPLGGHOYDOJHW WLO ]RQHU L
UHVWDGHQ 'HQQH O¡VQLQJV NRQVHNYHQVHU VHV Sn)LJXU
8GE\JQLQJDI+ROPHQ5HIVKDOH¡HQRJ6XQGE\1RUG
'HUHUVRPQ YQWLDIVQLWRSVWLOOHWHW´PDNVLPDO´VFHQDULRKYRULNNHEORWUHVWDGHQVPHQ RJVn+ROPHQVRJ5HIVKDOH¡HQVE\XGYLNOLQJVSRWHQWLDOHHUKHOWXGQ\WWHW3nEDJJUXQGDIGHWWH VFHQDULR HU GHU IRUHWDJHW HQ U NNH PRGHON¡UVOHU IRU GH RSVWLOOHGH DOWHUQDWLYHU 'HU HU PHG GHWWHVFHQDULRLNNHWDJHWVWLOOLQJWLOKYRUQnURJRPHQVnGDQE\XGYLNOLQJYLOEOLYHJHQQHP I¡UW%HUHJQLQJHUQHVNDODOHQHLOOXVWUHUH KYLONH WUDILNDOH NRQVHNYHQVHU HQ PDNVLPDO XGE\J QLQJNDQIRUYHQWHVDWIn
%HUHJQLQJHUQHW\GHUSnDWDOOHDGJDQJVYHMHWLO5HIVKDOH¡HQPYYLOEOLYHVW UNWEHODVWHWDI ELOWUDILN 'HWWHVN\OGHVDW GHQQH EHUHJQLQJVVLWXDWLRQ Q UPHUVLJNDSDFLWHWHQ IRU +DYQHWXQ QHOHQKYRUIRUGHUYLOY UHWLGVEHVSDUHOVHUYHGDWN¡UHDQGUHYHMHWLOGLVVHRPUnGHU'HWVNDO XQGHUVWUHJHVDWEHUHJQLQJHUQHDIWUDILNNHQLGHQQHVLWXDWLRQE\JJHUSnHQU NNHPHUHHOOHU PLQGUHXVLNUHDQWDJHOVHURPXGYLNOLQJHQ
'HWEHP UNHVDWKYLV+ROPHQ5HIVKDOH¡HQRJ6XQGE\1RUGXGE\JJHVHUGHUFDJDQJHVn PDQJH ELOLVWHU VRP NROOHNWLYH SDVVDJHUHU WLO 5HIVKDOH¡HQ RJ 6XQGE\ QRUG RJ ò JDQJH Vn PDQJHWLO+ROPHQ'LVVHEHUHJQLQJHUE\JJHUGRJSnDWGHQNROOHNWLYHEHWMHQLQJHUGHQVDP PHLDOOHEHUHJQLQJVDOWHUQDWLYHUQHVHDIVQLW'HWWHHUQ SSHUHDOLVWLVNLGHWGHWPnDQWDJHV DW+7YLO¡JHEHWMHQLQJHQDIRPUnGHWKYLVGHUIRUHWDJHVHQPDVVLYXGE\JQLQJ7LOVDPPHQOLJ QLQJOLJJHUGHWLOVYDUHQGHWDOIRUUHVWDGHQSn±ò,E\PLGWHQHUGHUIOHUHNROOHNWLYHWXUH HQGELOWXUH
)LJXU(IIHNWHQDIHQKDYQHWXQQHOHQRJHQ VSRUHWUHVWDGVERXOHYDUG
$QEHIDOLQJHUIRUGHWYLGHUHDUEHMGH
'HWHUXQGHUDUEHMGHWNRQVWDWHUHWDWYLVVHIRUKROGE¡UXQGHUV¡JHV\GHUOLJHUH+HUXQGHUI¡OJHU QRJOHDQEHIDOLQJHUIRUGHWYLGHUHDUEHMGHLLNNHSULRULWHUHWU NNHI¡OJH
• 7XUP¡QVWHUEHVNULYHOVHQ L PRGHONRPSOHNVHW E¡U VHV HIWHU L V¡PPHQH HYHQWXHOW NDQ GHW RYHUYHMHVRPGHUVNDORSE\JJHVHQKHOWQ\PRGHOIRUWXUIRUGHOLQJ%HJUXQGHOVHQKHUIRUHU DWYLVVH]RQHUVUHODWLRQHUYLUNHUXULPHOLJHLIRUKROGWLODOPLQGHOLJVXQGIRUQXIW6DPWDWWHVW PHGHQDQGHQPDWUL[HVWLPDWLRQVPHWRGH030(YLVWHVWRUHIRUVNHOOH0HWRGHQHUEHVNUH YHWL1LHOVHQ
• 'HWE¡URYHUYHMHVKYRUGDQDIWUDILNVDQHUHQGHIRUDQVWDOWQLQJHULGHQLQGUHE\NRQNUHWVNDO XGIRUPHV
• %HUHJQLQJHUIRUWUDILNVDQHULQJE¡UXGI¡UHVPHGIXOGWPRGHONRPSOHNV
• )RUVLQNHOVHULNU\GVNU\GVPRGHOOHULQJE¡ULQGGUDJHVLUXWHYDOJVDOJRULWPHQ
• 0DQJHGHWDLODOWHUQDWLYHUE¡UXQGHUV¡JHVIRUKYHUWKRYHGDOWHUQDWLYSn$PDJHUVLGHQ
• .RQVHNYHQVHUQHIRUODVWELOWUDILNNHQE¡UXQGHUV¡JHVJUXQGLJHUH
• %HW\GQLQJHQDIJHQHUHUHWWUDILNVRPI¡OJHDIWXQQHOHQE¡UXQGHUV¡JHVGDGHUHUWDOHRPHQ NUDIWLJIRUEHGULQJLLQIUDVWUXNWXUHQ3n,)3HUGHUEOHYHWIRUHWDJHWLQGOHGHQGHXQGHUV¡JHO VHUDIJHQHUHUHWWUDILN5HVXOWDWHUQHIRUHNRPPHJHWYDQVNHOLJHDWIRUWRONHGHUE¡UIRUVNHV PHUHLPHWRGHQ
• 'HWE¡UXQGHUV¡JHVKYLONHQHIIHNWURDGSULFLQJHOOHUERPSHQJHYLOKDYHLIRUELQGHOVHPHG HQKDYQHWXQQHO
• $OWHUQDWLYXGIRUPQLQJDIEXVUXWHUJHQQHPWXQQHOHQE¡URYHUYHMHV
.RQNOXVLRQ
$UWLNOHQJLYHUEHO JIRUDWGHWNDQY UHPHJHWQ\WWLJWDWLQGGUDJHWUDILNPRGHOOHULQJWLGOLJWL DUEHMGHW RPNULQJ VW¡UUH SODQSURMHNWHU LGHW VHOY WLOQ UPHGH EHUHJQLQJHU NDQ DIVO¡UH RYHUUD VNHQGHIRUKROG'LVVHNDQGHUHIWHULQGGUDJHVLGHQ UPHUH XQGHUV¡JHOVHURJ GHU NDQ WDJHV K¡MGHIRUGHPLGHWHQGHOLJHPRGHODUEHMGH,GHWI¡OJHQGHRSVXPPHUHVGHDIDUEHMGHWVUHVXO WDWHUGHUYDUPHVWRYHUUDVNHQGHRJVRPGHUPHGNDQY UHQ\WWLJHLGHQNRPPHQGHPHUHGH WDOMHUHGHXGUHGQLQJ
• 'HUYLOY UHIRUWULQVYLVORNDOWUDILNLKDYQHWXQQHOHQ
• 7XQQHOHQPHGI¡UHUHQP UNEDUDIODVWQLQJDIGHQLQGUHE\VHOYXGHQWUDILNVDQHULQJ
• 'HUEOLYHUNXQHQPDUJLQDORYHUIO\WQLQJDIWUDILNIUD0RWRUULQJYHMHQWLO+DYQHWXQQHOHQ
• 'HQ NROOHNWLYH WUDILN EOLYHU PHUH NRQNXUUHQFHG\JWLJ YHG XGE\JQLQJ DI UXWHUQH JHQQHP WXQQHOHQ
• 2YHUIO\WQLQJDINROOHNWLYHWXUHIUDUHVWDGVEDQHUQHWLOELOWXUHEOLYHUNXQPDUJLQDO
• (QWUDILNVDQHULQJDILQGUHE\LIRUELQGHOVHPHGRSI¡UHOVHDIHQKDYQHWXQQHOYLOLNNHKDYH PDUNDQWHIIHNWSnWUDILNNHQXQGHUDIODVWQLQJSnDQGUHJDGHUHQG.QLSSHOVEUR
• 8DQVHWKYRUGDQ+DYQHWXQQHOHQIRUELQGHVWLOYHMQHWWHWSn$PDJHUYLOHQVWRUGHODIWUDILN NHQIUDKDYQHWXQQHOHQIRUWV WWHDG$PDJHU6WUDQGYHMHOOHUVPnYHMHSnVWDPDJHU
• (QK¡MNODVVHIRUELQGHOVHWLO9HVWDPDJHUYLOLGHQEHQ\WWHGHYDULDQWNXQEOLYHEHODVWHWDIFD DIWUDILNNHQIUDHQ+DYQHWXQQHO
(Q\GHUOLJHUHNRQNOXVLRQHUDWGHQDQYHQGWHVWUDWHJLPHGKHQV\QWLORSVWLOOLQJDIPDQJHRYHU RUGQHGHVFHQDULHURJDOWHUQDWLYHUKDUEnUHWIUXJW6nOHGHVKDUGHLQGOHGHQGHEHUHJQLQJHUI¡UW WLODWIOHUHDOWHUQDWLYHUNXQQHIRUNDVWHVVRPY UHQGHXLQWHUHVVDQWH6WUDWHJLHQKDUJDYQHWDU EHMGHWPHGDWXGSHJHSUREOHPRPUnGHU±JHRJUDILVNHVnYHOVRPIDJOLJH±LIRUELQGHOVHPHG YXUGHULQJDIGHWUDILNDOHNRQVHNYHQVHUDIHQKDYHWXQQHO
5HIHUHQFHU
&DUO%UR*UXSSHQUHVWDGVVHOVNDEHW1\E\EDQHL.¡EHQKDYQ7UDILNPRGHO%LQG3URJQRVHU 7UDILN2NWREHU
.¡EHQKDYQV .RPPXQH 6WDGVLQJHQL¡UHQV 'LUHNWRUDW 9HMDIGHOLQJHQ,QGUH %\ RJ +DYQHWXQQHOHQ 0XOLJKHGHU9LVLRQHU
1LHOVHQ2WWR$QNHU7HNQLVNGRNXPHQWDWLRQIRUGHQDQYHQGWHVLPXOHULQJWLOIRUGHOLQJDIODVWELOWUD ILNSnWUDILNQHWWHWL+RYHGVWDGVUHJLRQHQ%LODJL0LOM¡EHODVWQLQJYHGJRGVWUDQVSRUWPHGELORJ VNLEHWSLORWSURMHNWRP+RYHGVWDGVUHJLRQHQ.ULVWHQ1HGHUJDDUG 3HWHU0DVNHOO'DQPDUNV0LOM¡
XQGHUV¡JHOVHU+DQGHOVK¡MVNROHQL.EKRJ.EKV+DYQ-XOL
1LHOVHQ2WWR$QNHU1\HPRGHOOHUIRUUXWHYDOJ$UWLNHOWLO7UDILNGDJHSn$8&%LQGV
$XJXVW
1LHOVHQ2WWR$QNHU'R6WRFKDVWLF7UDIILF$VVLJQPHQW0RGHOV&RQVLGHU'LIIHUHQFHVLQ5RDG8VHUV 8WLOLW\)XQFWLRQV"WK(XURSHDQ7UDQVSRUW)RUXP375&$QQXDO0HHWLQJ8[EULGJH8.6HPLQDU 0
1LHOVHQ2WWR$QNHU0XOWL3DWK2'0DWUL[(VWLPDWLRQ030(EDVHGRQ6WRFKDVWLF8VHU(TXLOL EULXP7UDIILF$VVLJQPHQW75%DQQXDOPHHWLQJ:DVKLQJWRQ-DQXDU\3UHSULQWV9RO,,, 1LHOVHQ2WWR$QNHU7KRPDV,VUDHOVHQ(ULN5XGH1LHOVHQ*,6EDVHGPHWKRGVIRUHVWDEOLVKLQJWKH GDWDIRXQGDWLRQIRUWUDIILFPRGHOVWK$QQ(65,8VHU&RQIHUHQFH6DQ'LHJR86$-XO\
7UDILNPLQLVWHULHWVWOLJKDYQHWXQQHOL.¡EHQKDYQ
7UDQVSRUWUnGHW+DYQHWXQQHOL.¡EHQKDYQYXUGHULQJHURJKRYHGVS¡UJVPnO0DUWV5DSSRUW QU
9HMGLUHNWRUDWHW7UDILNEHUHJQLQJHU.¡EHQKDYQV¡VWOLJHRPIDUWVYHM+DYQHWXQQHO$SULO8G NDVW
