Kriegers Flak Wind Farm

(1)

Kriegers Flak Wind Farm

2 3 . A U G U S T 2 0 1 9

Noise Impact Assessment

(2)

EMD International A/S

R E C I P I E N T Vattenfall Vindkraft RU204A SE-962 80 Jokkmokk

Attn. Merete Bertelsen

D A T E 23 August 2019

P R E P A R E D B Y EMD International A/S Niels Jernes Vej 10 DK- 9220 Aalborg T: + 45 96 35 44 44 E: emd@emd.dk

P R I N C I P A L C O N S U L T A N T Karina Bredelle EMD-DK

A P P R O V E D B Y Thomas Sørensen

EMD-DK

D O C U M E N T 190823_19046_C_KB_0

Kriegers Flak

(3)

EMD International A/S

D O C U M E N T R E V I S I O N S

Rev i si on Da te Rep or t n o . Ch ap t er (s ) De scr ip t ion o f

Pu r p os e/Ch an ge s

0 23.08.2019 190823_19046_C_KB_0 All Initial report

K E Y T O D O C U M E N T C L A S S I F I C A T I O N Cl as s if ic at io n

Strictly Confidential: Recipients only

Private and Confidential: For disclosure to individuals directly concerned within the recipient’s organisation

Commercial in Confidence: Not to be disclosed outside the recipient’s organisation

Client’s Discretion: Distribution at the discretion of the client subject to contractual agreement Published: Available to the general public

L I A B I L I T I E S

EMD International A/S (EMD) does not warrant, guarantee or make any representations regarding the delivered consultancy material caused by errors or omissions in the delivered data. EMD cannot be held liable for erroneous results caused by inaccuracy, limitations or malfunctioning of models or software used.

For any claim whatsoever related to the subject matter of this consultancy job, the liability of EMD for actual

damages, regardless of the form of action, shall be limited to the total amount paid to EMD for the services

provided as part of this consultancy job. Separate insurance cover for extended liability can be provided upon

request, but at the expense of the Client.

(4)

EMD International A/S

1 Executive Summary

This report presents the results of the noise assessment for the Kriegers Flak wind farm project in Denmark . The project consists of 72 Siemens SWT 8 MW wind turbines with 104.9 m hub height.

The calculation methods follow the previous Danish regulation (Bekendtgørelse nr 1736 21/12/2015 from the Danish Environmental Agency) which is valid for Kriegers Flak.

The calculations are performed for both normal and low frequency noise. A preliminary calculation is made to check whether any existing wind turbines shall be included in the calculation according to the “15 dB rule”. The calculations show that in none of the cases, it is required to include existing turbines.

Finally for both the normal and low frequency noise, the noise immision of Kriegers Flak wind farm complies with

the Danish Regulation, bekendtgørelse nr.1736 21/12/2015.

(5)

EMD International A/S

Content

1 Executive Summary ... 3

2 Method ... 6

3 Normal Noise ... 8

3.1 15db rule consequence zone ... 8

3.2 Results Normal Noise ... 9

4 Low Frequency Noise ... 11

4.1 15db rule consequence zone ... 11

4.2 Results Low frequency Noise ... 12

WindPRO calculation: Normal noise ... 14

WindPRO calculation: Low Frequency noise ... 20

(6)

EMD International A/S

List of Figures

Figure 1 Noise limits at the dwellings... 6

Figure 2. Source noise level (Normal noise) ... 6

Figure 3. Source noise level (Low Frequency noise)... 7

Figure 4. 15 dB(A) rule lines at 6m/s for normal noise ... 8

Figure 5. 15 dB(A) rule lines at 8m/s for normal noise ... 8

Figure 6. Noise calculation for normal noise at 6m/s ... 9

Figure 7. Noise calculation results for normal noise at 8m/s ... 10

Figure 8. 15 dB(A) rule lines at 6m/s for low frequency noise ... 11

Figure 9. 15 dB(A) rule lines at 8m/s for low frequency noise ... 12

Figure 10. Low Frequency noise calculation results for normal noise at 6m/s ... 13

Figure 11. Low Frequency noise calculation results for normal noise at 8m/s ... 13

List of tables

Table 1. Value of the 15 dB line delimiting the consequence zone for the different thresholds ... 7

(7)

EMD International A/S

2 Method

The noise propagation model is described in “Bekendtgørelse nr 1736 af 21/12/2015” from the Danish Agency.

The propagation model takes into account that the wind turbines are defined as Offshore turbines.

Two noise targets are considered: Normal noise in the range 63 Hz to 10 kHz and low frequency noise from 10 Hz to 160 Hz. In both cases the aggregated dB(A) value at the receptors are compared to the noise target.

The noise targets for normal noise and low frequency noise are described below.

Figure 1 Noise limits at the dwellings

As offshore wind turbines a lower ground attenuation is used than for onshore wind turbines. In the low frequency calculation a transition zone at the coastline (200m) is included behind which onshore ground attenuation is used.

The normal range noise calculation does not include a coastline transition zone.

The source noise levels of the wind turbine has been provided by Vattenfall and are presented in Figure 2 and Figure 3.

Figure 2. Source noise level (Normal noise)

(8)

EMD International A/S

Figure 3. Source noise level (Low Frequency noise)

According to the guideline from the Environmental Agency, neighbors to existing wind turbines have to be re- assessed if the contribution of the Kriegers Flak wind farm at these neighbors is larger than 15 dB below the noise received from existing wind turbines. The calculation of a noise line equivalent to the threshold minus 15 dB, called

“15 dB line” or consequence zone has been made in each of the cases (normal and low frequency noise). The “15 dB lines” relating to the thresholds listed in Figure 1 are presented in Table 1.

Table 1. Value of the 15 dB line delimiting the consequence zone for the different thresholds

Typ e o f Dem an d Th r es h old

[d B( A) ]

“1 5 d B l in e ” [d B ( A)]

Normal noise, open land, 8m/s 44 29

Normal noise, open land, 6m/s 42 27

Normal noise, recreational area, 8m/s 39 24

Normal noise, recreational area, 6m/s 37 22

Low Frequency noise 20 5

In none of the cases there are any neighbors to existing turbines within the consequence zone. Any area to which the Kriegers Flak turbines contribute with a noise impact of less than 15 dB below the relevant threshold is not considered impacted and therefore not included in the calculation. Therefore, no neighbors to existing wind turbines have been considered in the calculations and no existing wind turbines have been included.

In the following sections, the maps for the 15 dB consequence zone and for the resulting noise are presented for both Normal and Low Frequency noise.

The noise impact from Kriegers Flak is below the thresholds listed in figure 1 for all receptors onshore and in

compliance with the regulation.

(9)

EMD International A/S

3 Normal Noise

3.1 15db rule consequence zone

Figure 4. 15 dB(A) rule lines at 6m/s for normal noise

Figure 5. 15 dB(A) rule lines at 8m/s for normal noise

(10)

EMD International A/S

3.2 Results Normal Noise

Since the noise lines are not reaching the coast, it can be concluded that the noise limits are fulfilled.

Figure 6. Noise calculation for normal noise at 6m/s

(11)

EMD International A/S

Figure 7. Noise calculation results for normal noise at 8m/s

(12)

EMD International A/S

4 Low Frequency Noise

4.1 15db rule consequence zone

Since no neighbors to existing turbines are close to or within the consequence zone, no existing turbines are included in the calculation.

Figure 8. 15 dB(A) rule lines at 6m/s for low frequency noise

(13)

EMD International A/S

Figure 9. 15 dB(A) rule lines at 8m/s for low frequency noise

The low frequency noise level at the closest relevant point to the closest existing turbine has been calculated. The noise immission of Kriegers Flak wind turbines alone at this point (Nørrebyvej 31) is calculated to 3.8 dB(A). Adding the contribution of the existing turbine, the noise level becomes 4.0 dB(A), which is well below the threshold of 20 dB(A).

4.2 Results Low frequency Noise

Since the noise lines are not reaching the coast, it can be concluded that the noise is below the threshold and the

regulation met.

(14)

EMD International A/S

Figure 10. Low Frequency noise calculation results for normal noise at 6m/s

(15)

EMD International A/S

WindPRO calculation: Normal noise

(16)

EMD International A/S

Project:

Kr ieger s-Flak (1 9 0 4 6 )

Description:

Disclaimer

EMD International A/S does not warrant, guarantee or make any representations regarding the delivered consultancy material caused by errors or omissions in the delivered data. EMD cannot be held liable for erroneous results caused by inaccuracy, limitations or malfunctioning of models or software used. For any claim whatsoever related to the subject matter of this consultancy service, the liability of EMD International A/S for actual damages, regardless of the form of action, shall be limited to the total amount paid to EMD International for the services provided as part of this consultancy service. Separate insurance cover for extended liability can be provided upon request, but at the expense of the Client.

Licensed user:

EMD International A/S Niels Jernes Vej 101 DK-9220 Aalborg Ø +45 9635 4444 Karina Bredelle

Calculated:

06/05/2019 10:34/3.3.252

DECIBEL - Main Result

Calculation: 72 x SWT 8MW, Normal noise DK, 2015 rules Noise calculation model:

Danish 2011 and 2015

The calculation is based on the "Bekendtgørelse nr 1736 af 21/12/2015" from the Danish Environmental Agency.

The noise impact from WTGs are not allowed to exceed the following limits: (Wind speeds in 10 m height)

1) At outdoor areas maximum 15 m from neighbor settlements in the open land.

a) 44 db(A) at wind speed 8 m/s.

b) 42 db(A) at wind speed 6 m/s.

2) At outdoor areas in residential or recreational areas.

a) 39 db(A) at wind speed 8 m/s in residential areas.

b) 37 db(A) at wind speed 6 m/s in residential areas.

The low frequency noise impact from WTGs are not allowed to exceed 20 dB indoor at wind speeds 8 and 6 m/s

The limits are not to be taken into acount for houses belonging to WTG owner All coordinates are in

UTM (north)-ETRS89 Zone: 33

Scale 1:400,000 New WTG

WT Gs

WTG type Noise data

Easting Northing Z Row data/Description Valid Manufact. Type-generator Power, Rotor Hub Creator Name First LwaRef Last LwaRef Pure

rated diameter height wind wind tones

speed speed

[m] [kW] [m] [m] [m/s] [dB(A)] [m/s] [dB(A)]

1 361,045 6,104,339 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 110.5 8.0 115.0 No 2 358,720 6,103,546 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 110.5 8.0 115.0 No 3 360,587 6,103,205 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 110.5 8.0 115.0 No 4 357,411 6,103,022 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 110.5 8.0 115.0 No 5 360,299 6,101,966 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 110.5 8.0 115.0 No 6 357,213 6,101,780 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 110.5 8.0 115.0 No 7 360,371 6,100,695 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 110.5 8.0 115.0 No 8 356,942 6,100,720 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 110.5 8.0 115.0 No 9 356,939 6,099,636 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 110.5 8.0 115.0 No 10 360,598 6,099,141 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 110.5 8.0 115.0 No 11 356,846 6,098,561 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 110.5 8.0 115.0 No 12 360,774 6,098,042 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 110.5 8.0 115.0 No 13 356,492 6,097,598 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 110.5 8.0 115.0 No 14 360,304 6,096,814 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 110.5 8.0 115.0 No 15 356,848 6,096,484 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 110.5 8.0 115.0 No 16 362,113 6,095,767 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 110.5 8.0 115.0 No 17 359,898 6,095,222 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 110.5 8.0 115.0 No 18 357,204 6,095,370 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 110.5 8.0 115.0 No 19 363,821 6,094,620 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 110.5 8.0 115.0 No 20 365,819 6,093,644 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 110.5 8.0 115.0 No 21 357,644 6,094,252 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 110.5 8.0 115.0 No 22 359,434 6,094,004 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 110.5 8.0 115.0 No 23 361,398 6,093,745 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 110.5 8.0 115.0 No 24 363,545 6,093,560 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 110.5 8.0 115.0 No 25 369,615 6,107,393 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 110.5 8.0 115.0 No 26 370,472 6,106,868 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 110.5 8.0 115.0 No 27 368,409 6,106,951 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 110.5 8.0 115.0 No 28 367,192 6,106,518 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 110.5 8.0 115.0 No 29 371,493 6,106,148 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 110.5 8.0 115.0 No 30 372,425 6,105,436 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 110.5 8.0 115.0 No 31 365,521 6,105,942 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 110.5 8.0 115.0 No 32 369,962 6,105,827 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 110.5 8.0 115.0 No 33 367,360 6,105,330 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 110.5 8.0 115.0 No 34 363,932 6,105,355 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 110.5 8.0 115.0 No 35 373,694 6,104,516 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 110.5 8.0 115.0 No 36 365,074 6,104,985 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 110.5 8.0 115.0 No 37 369,270 6,104,444 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 110.5 8.0 115.0 No 38 374,721 6,103,794 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 110.5 8.0 115.0 No 40 371,219 6,104,005 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 110.5 8.0 115.0 No 41 375,643 6,103,002 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 110.5 8.0 115.0 No 42 373,210 6,103,021 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 110.5 8.0 115.0 No 43 367,795 6,103,036 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 110.5 8.0 115.0 No 44 370,101 6,102,653 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 110.5 8.0 115.0 No 45 376,554 6,102,011 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 110.5 8.0 115.0 No 46 372,825 6,101,704 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 110.5 8.0 115.0 No 47 377,291 6,101,135 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 110.5 8.0 115.0 No 48 369,838 6,101,596 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 110.5 8.0 115.0 No 49 375,028 6,101,059 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 110.5 8.0 115.0 No 50 378,118 6,100,251 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 110.5 8.0 115.0 No 51 368,514 6,100,897 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 110.5 8.0 115.0 No 52 372,434 6,100,289 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 110.5 8.0 115.0 No 53 369,087 6,100,216 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 110.5 8.0 115.0 No 54 378,855 6,099,376 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 110.5 8.0 115.0 No

(17)

EMD International A/S

windPRO 3.3.270 by EMD International A/S, Tel. +45 96 35 44 44, www.emd.dk, windpro@emd.dk 22/08/2019 11:08 / 2

windPRO

Project:

Kr ieger s-Flak (1 9 0 4 6 )

Description:

Disclaimer

Licensed user:

EMD International A/S Niels Jernes Vej 101 DK-9220 Aalborg Ø +45 9635 4444 Karina Bredelle

Calculated:

06/05/2019 10:34/3.3.252

DECIBEL - Main Result

Calculation: 72 x SWT 8MW, Normal noise DK, 2015 rules

...continued from previous page

Easting Northing Z Row data/Description Valid Manufact. Type-generator Power, Rotor Hub Creator Name First LwaRef Last LwaRef Pure

rated diameter height wind wind tones

speed speed

56 379,510 6,098,597 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 110.5 8.0 115.0 No 57 370,362 6,099,294 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 110.5 8.0 115.0 No 58 371,354 6,098,582 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 110.5 8.0 115.0 No 59 373,571 6,098,386 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 110.5 8.0 115.0 No 60 375,960 6,097,990 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 110.5 8.0 115.0 No 61 378,790 6,097,576 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 110.5 8.0 115.0 No 62 371,933 6,097,624 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 110.5 8.0 115.0 No 63 375,218 6,096,980 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 110.5 8.0 115.0 No 64 377,868 6,096,301 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 110.5 8.0 115.0 No 65 372,030 6,096,582 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 110.5 8.0 115.0 No 66 374,854 6,095,934 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 110.5 8.0 115.0 No 67 372,397 6,095,806 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 110.5 8.0 115.0 No 68 376,872 6,095,213 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 110.5 8.0 115.0 No 69 371,799 6,095,017 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 110.5 8.0 115.0 No 70 375,384 6,094,709 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 110.5 8.0 115.0 No 71 373,635 6,094,318 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 110.5 8.0 115.0 No 75 369,316 6,106,456 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 110.5 8.0 115.0 No 77 372,985 6,094,984 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 110.5 8.0 115.0 No

(18)

EMD International A/S

Project:

Kr ieger s-Flak (1 9 0 4 6 )

Description:

Disclaimer

Licensed user:

EMD International A/S Niels Jernes Vej 101 DK-9220 Aalborg Ø +45 9635 4444 Karina Bredelle

Calculated:

06/05/2019 10:34/3.3.252

DECIBEL - Assumptions for noise calculation Calculation: 72 x SWT 8MW, Normal noise DK, 2015 rules Noise calculation model:

Danish 2011 and 2015 Wind speed (in 10 m height):

6.0 m/s - 8.0 m/s, step 2.0 m/s Terrain reduction:

-1.5 dB(A) Onshore -3 dB(A) Offshore

Meteorological coefficient, C0:

0.0 dB

Type of demand in calculation:

1: WTG noise is compared to demand (DK, DE, SE, NL etc.) Noise values in calculation:

All noise values are mean values (Lwa) (Normal) Pure tones:

Pure tones penalty is added to total noise impact at receptors Noise sensitive area

Height above ground level, when no value in NSA object:

1.5 m; Don't allow override of model height with height from NSA object Uncertainty margin:

0.0 dB; Uncertainty margin in NSA has priority

Deviation from "official" noise demands. Negative is more restrictive, positive is less restrictive.:

0.0 dB(A)

Octave data required Frequency dependent air absorption

63 125 250 500 1,000 2,000 4,000 8,000

[dB/km] [dB/km] [dB/km] [dB/km] [dB/km] [dB/km] [dB/km] [dB/km]

0.10 0.40 1.00 2.00 3.60 8.80 29.00 104.50

WT G: Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 167.0 !O!

Noise: Standard - Kriegers Flak

Source Source/Date Creator Edited Siemens Gamesa 29/04/2019 USER 06/05/2019 09:14 Document: SGRE OF S&PR S PPL BMWTG-DK00328-100000015264-00

Octave data

Status Wind speed LwA,ref Pure tones 63 125 250 500 1000 2000 4000 8000 [m/s] [dB(A)] [dB] [dB] [dB] [dB] [dB] [dB] [dB] [dB]

From Windcat 6.0 110.5 No 93.8 99.4 102.1 102.8 104.0 104.6 100.7 88.9

From Windcat 8.0 115.0 No 98.3 103.9 106.6 107.3 108.5 109.1 105.2 93.4

(19)

EMD International A/S

windPRO

Project:

Kr ieger s-Flak (1 9 0 4 6 )

Description:

Disclaimer

Licensed user:

EMD International A/S Niels Jernes Vej 101 DK-9220 Aalborg Ø +45 9635 4444 Karina Bredelle

Calculated:

06/05/2019 10:34/3.3.252

DECIBEL - Map 6.0 m/s

Calculation: 72 x SWT 8MW, Normal noise DK, 2015 rules

0 5 10 15 20 km

Map: EMD OpenStreetMap_ScreendumpCopy003 , Print scale 1:300,000, Map center UTM (north)-ETRS89 Zone: 33 East: 368,001 North: 6,100,476 New WTG

Noise calculation model: Danish 2011 and 2015. Wind speed: 6.0 m/s Height above sea level from active line object

Noise [dB(A)]

37

42

(20)

EMD International A/S

Project:

Kr ieger s-Flak (1 9 0 4 6 )

Description:

Disclaimer

Licensed user:

EMD International A/S Niels Jernes Vej 101 DK-9220 Aalborg Ø +45 9635 4444 Karina Bredelle

Calculated:

06/05/2019 10:34/3.3.252

DECIBEL - Map 8.0 m/s

Calculation: 72 x SWT 8MW, Normal noise DK, 2015 rules

0 5 10 15 20 km

Map: EMD OpenStreetMap_ScreendumpCopy003 , Print scale 1:300,000, Map center UTM (north)-ETRS89 Zone: 33 East: 368,001 North: 6,100,476 New WTG

Noise calculation model: Danish 2011 and 2015. Wind speed: 8.0 m/s

Noise [dB(A)]

39

44

(21)

EMD International A/S

WindPRO calculation: Low

Frequency noise

(22)

EMD International A/S

Project:

Kr ieger s-Flak (1 9 0 4 6 )

Description:

Disclaimer

Licensed user:

EMD International A/S Niels Jernes Vej 101 DK-9220 Aalborg Ø +45 9635 4444 Karina Bredelle

Calculated:

06/05/2019 16:05/3.3.252

DECIBEL - Main Result

Calculation: 72 x SWT 8MW, Low F requency , 2015 rules Noise calculation model:

Danish Low frequency 2011 and 2015

The calculation is based on the "Bekendtgørelse nr 1736 af 21/12/2015" from the Danish Environmental Agency.

The noise impact from WTGs are not allowed to exceed the following limits: (Wind speeds in 10 m height)

1) At outdoor areas maximum 15 m from neighbor settlements in the open land.

a) 44 db(A) at wind speed 8 m/s.

b) 42 db(A) at wind speed 6 m/s.

2) At outdoor areas in residential or recreational areas.

a) 39 db(A) at wind speed 8 m/s in residential areas.

b) 37 db(A) at wind speed 6 m/s in residential areas.

The low frequency noise impact from WTGs are not allowed to exceed 20 dB indoor at wind speeds 8 and 6 m/s

The limits are not to be taken into acount for houses belonging to WTG owner Den lavfrekvente støj beregnes indendøre og må ikke overstige 20 dB ved vindhastigheder på 6 og 8 m/s i 10 m højde

All coordinates are in UTM (north)-ETRS89 Zone: 33

Scale 1:400,000 New WTG

WT Gs

Easting Northing Z Row data/Description Valid Manufact. Type-generator Power, Rotor Hub Offshore Creator Name First LwaRef Last LwaRef

rated diameter height wind wind

speed speed

1 361,045 6,104,339 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 Yes USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 100.6 8.0 105.1 2 358,720 6,103,546 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 Yes USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 100.6 8.0 105.1 3 360,587 6,103,205 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 Yes USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 100.6 8.0 105.1 4 357,411 6,103,022 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 Yes USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 100.6 8.0 105.1 5 360,299 6,101,966 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 Yes USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 100.6 8.0 105.1 6 357,213 6,101,780 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 Yes USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 100.6 8.0 105.1 7 360,371 6,100,695 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 Yes USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 100.6 8.0 105.1 8 356,942 6,100,720 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 Yes USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 100.6 8.0 105.1 9 356,939 6,099,636 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 Yes USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 100.6 8.0 105.1 10 360,598 6,099,141 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 Yes USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 100.6 8.0 105.1 11 356,846 6,098,561 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 Yes USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 100.6 8.0 105.1 12 360,774 6,098,042 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 Yes USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 100.6 8.0 105.1 13 356,492 6,097,598 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 Yes USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 100.6 8.0 105.1 14 360,304 6,096,814 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 Yes USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 100.6 8.0 105.1 15 356,848 6,096,484 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 Yes USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 100.6 8.0 105.1 16 362,113 6,095,767 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 Yes USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 100.6 8.0 105.1 17 359,898 6,095,222 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 Yes USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 100.6 8.0 105.1 18 357,204 6,095,370 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 Yes USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 100.6 8.0 105.1 19 363,821 6,094,620 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 Yes USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 100.6 8.0 105.1 20 365,819 6,093,644 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 Yes USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 100.6 8.0 105.1 21 357,644 6,094,252 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 Yes USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 100.6 8.0 105.1 22 359,434 6,094,004 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 Yes USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 100.6 8.0 105.1 23 361,398 6,093,745 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 Yes USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 100.6 8.0 105.1 24 363,545 6,093,560 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 Yes USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 100.6 8.0 105.1 25 369,615 6,107,393 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 Yes USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 100.6 8.0 105.1 26 370,472 6,106,868 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 Yes USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 100.6 8.0 105.1 27 368,409 6,106,951 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 Yes USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 100.6 8.0 105.1 28 367,192 6,106,518 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 Yes USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 100.6 8.0 105.1 29 371,493 6,106,148 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 Yes USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 100.6 8.0 105.1 30 372,425 6,105,436 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 Yes USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 100.6 8.0 105.1 31 365,521 6,105,942 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 Yes USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 100.6 8.0 105.1 32 369,962 6,105,827 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 Yes USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 100.6 8.0 105.1 33 367,360 6,105,330 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 Yes USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 100.6 8.0 105.1 34 363,932 6,105,355 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 Yes USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 100.6 8.0 105.1 35 373,694 6,104,516 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 Yes USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 100.6 8.0 105.1 36 365,074 6,104,985 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 Yes USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 100.6 8.0 105.1 37 369,270 6,104,444 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 Yes USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 100.6 8.0 105.1 38 374,721 6,103,794 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 Yes USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 100.6 8.0 105.1 39 371,219 6,104,005 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 Yes USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 100.6 8.0 105.1 40 375,643 6,103,002 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 Yes USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 100.6 8.0 105.1 41 373,210 6,103,021 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 Yes USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 100.6 8.0 105.1 42 367,795 6,103,036 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 Yes USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 100.6 8.0 105.1 43 370,101 6,102,653 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 Yes USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 100.6 8.0 105.1 44 376,554 6,102,011 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 Yes USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 100.6 8.0 105.1 45 372,825 6,101,704 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 Yes USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 100.6 8.0 105.1 46 377,291 6,101,135 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 Yes USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 100.6 8.0 105.1 47 369,838 6,101,596 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 Yes USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 100.6 8.0 105.1 48 375,028 6,101,059 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 Yes USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 100.6 8.0 105.1 49 378,118 6,100,251 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 Yes USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 100.6 8.0 105.1 50 368,514 6,100,897 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 Yes USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 100.6 8.0 105.1 51 372,434 6,100,289 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 Yes USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 100.6 8.0 105.1 52 369,087 6,100,216 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 Yes USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 100.6 8.0 105.1 53 378,855 6,099,376 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 Yes USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 100.6 8.0 105.1 54 375,622 6,099,530 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 Yes USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 100.6 8.0 105.1

(23)

EMD International A/S

windPRO

Project:

Kr ieger s-Flak (1 9 0 4 6 )

Description:

Disclaimer

Licensed user:

EMD International A/S Niels Jernes Vej 101 DK-9220 Aalborg Ø +45 9635 4444 Karina Bredelle

Calculated:

06/05/2019 16:05/3.3.252

DECIBEL - Main Result

Calculation: 72 x SWT 8MW, Low F requency , 2015 rules

...continued from previous page

Easting Northing Z Row data/Description Valid Manufact. Type-generator Power, Rotor Hub Offshore Creator Name First LwaRef Last LwaRef

rated diameter height wind wind

speed speed

56 370,362 6,099,294 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 Yes USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 100.6 8.0 105.1 57 371,354 6,098,582 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 Yes USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 100.6 8.0 105.1 58 373,571 6,098,386 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 Yes USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 100.6 8.0 105.1 59 375,960 6,097,990 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 Yes USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 100.6 8.0 105.1 60 378,790 6,097,576 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 Yes USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 100.6 8.0 105.1 61 371,933 6,097,624 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 Yes USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 100.6 8.0 105.1 62 375,218 6,096,980 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 Yes USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 100.6 8.0 105.1 63 377,868 6,096,301 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 Yes USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 100.6 8.0 105.1 64 372,030 6,096,582 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 Yes USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 100.6 8.0 105.1 65 374,854 6,095,934 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 Yes USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 100.6 8.0 105.1 66 372,397 6,095,806 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 Yes USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 100.6 8.0 105.1 67 376,872 6,095,213 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 Yes USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 100.6 8.0 105.1 68 371,799 6,095,017 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 Yes USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 100.6 8.0 105.1 69 375,384 6,094,709 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 Yes USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 100.6 8.0 105.1 70 373,635 6,094,318 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 Yes USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 100.6 8.0 105.1 71 369,316 6,106,456 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 Yes USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 100.6 8.0 105.1 72 372,985 6,094,984 0.0 Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 ...Yes Siemens SWT-8.0-167-8,000 8,000 167.0 104.9 Yes USER Standard - Kriegers Flak 6.0 100.6 8.0 105.1

(24)

EMD International A/S

Project:

Kr ieger s-Flak (1 9 0 4 6 )

Description:

Disclaimer

Licensed user:

EMD International A/S Niels Jernes Vej 101 DK-9220 Aalborg Ø +45 9635 4444 Karina Bredelle

Calculated:

06/05/2019 16:05/3.3.252

DECIBEL - Assumptions for noise calculation Calculation: 72 x SWT 8MW, Low F requency , 2015 rules Noise calculation model:

Danish Low frequency 2011 and 2015 Wind speed (in 10 m height):

6.0 m/s - 8.0 m/s, step 2.0 m/s Ground attenuation:

General, Ground factor: 1.0 Meteorological coefficient, C0:

0.0 dB

Type of demand in calculation:

1: WTG noise is compared to demand (DK, DE, SE, NL etc.) Noise values in calculation:

All noise values are mean values (Lwa) (Normal) Pure tones:

Pure tone penalty is subtracted from demand WTG catalogue

Height above ground level, when no value in NSA object:

1.5 m; Don't allow override of model height with height from NSA object Uncertainty margin:

0.0 dB; Uncertainty margin in NSA has priority

Deviation from "official" noise demands. Negative is more restrictive, positive is less restrictive.:

0.0 dB(A)

Low frequency calculation dLsigma

10.0 Hz 12.5 Hz 16.0 Hz 20.0 Hz 25.0 Hz 31.5 Hz 40.0 Hz 50.0 Hz 63.0 Hz 80.0 Hz 100.0 Hz 125.0 Hz 160.0 Hz

[dB] [dB] [dB] [dB] [dB] [dB] [dB] [dB] [dB] [dB] [dB] [dB] [dB]

4.9 5.9 4.6 6.6 8.4 10.8 11.4 13.0 16.6 19.7 21.2 20.2 21.2

Area object used for water areas: Area object (Heights a.g.l. for e.g. Forest (ORA tool) or ZVI obstructions): REGIONS_Kriegers-Flak (19046)_0.w2r (1): water WT G: Siemens SWT-8.0-167 8000 167.0 !O!

Noise: Standard - Kriegers Flak

Source Source/Date Creator Edited Siemens Gamesa 29/04/2019 USER 06/05/2019 11:18 Document: SGRE OF S&PR S PPL BMWTG-DK00328-100000015264-00

Low frequency data

Status Wind LwA,ref 10.0 Hz 12.5 Hz 16.0 Hz 20.0 Hz 25.0 Hz 31.5 Hz 40.0 Hz 50.0 Hz 63.0 Hz 80.0 Hz 100.0 125.0 160.0 Hz

speed Hz Hz

[m/s] [dB(A)] [dB] [dB] [dB] [dB] [dB] [dB] [dB] [dB] [dB] [dB] [dB] [dB] [dB]

From Windcat 6.0 100.6 53.5 58.8 64.7 69.6 74.0 78.0 81.9 85.4 88.7 91.2 92.8 94.6 96.0

From Windcat 8.0 105.1 58.0 63.3 69.2 74.1 78.5 82.5 86.4 89.9 93.2 95.7 97.3 99.1 100.5

(25)

EMD International A/S

windPRO

Project:

Kr ieger s-Flak (1 9 0 4 6 )

Description:

Disclaimer

Licensed user:

EMD International A/S Niels Jernes Vej 101 DK-9220 Aalborg Ø +45 9635 4444 Karina Bredelle

Calculated:

06/05/2019 16:05/3.3.252

DECIBEL - Map 6.0 m/s

Calculation: 72 x SWT 8MW, Low F requency , 2015 rules

0 5 10 15 20 km

Map: EMD OpenStreetMap_ScreendumpCopy003 , Print scale 1:400,000, Map center UTM (north)-ETRS89 Zone: 33 East: 368,001 North: 6,100,476 New WTG

Noise calculation model: Danish Low frequency 2011 and 2015. Wind speed: 6.0 m/s Height above sea level: 0.0 m

Noise [dB(A)]

20

(26)

EMD International A/S

Project:

Kr ieger s-Flak (1 9 0 4 6 )

Description:

Disclaimer

Licensed user:

EMD International A/S Niels Jernes Vej 101 DK-9220 Aalborg Ø +45 9635 4444 Karina Bredelle

Calculated: